MovieChat Forums > What Is a Woman? (2022) Discussion > sex change Is NOT Mental Illness

sex change Is NOT Mental Illness


its not people aren't comfortable with there assigned Gender at Birth that should be celebrate not revieled besides they are welcome to have a seat at the table as should everyone!

reply

Sex change is impossible. Having cosmetic surgery to look more like someone of the opposite sex does not actually change ones sex.

reply

Still Not a Mental illness

reply

Well psychiatry isn't hard science so frankly don't care how it's currently defined. Some years ago it was considered such until very recently a shift in public opinion made them change it.

Either way I don't think it's a good message for children that they need surgery and to become lifelong patients because of some weird view that their body and mind need to "match" (based on gender stereotypes).

reply

no one is forcing its still a CHOICE let he/she have that CHOICE don't take it away if my kid isn't comfortable with his/her assign gender they should have that CHOICE I will still LOVE them no matter what

reply

You can love your anorexic daughter and without supporting her behaviour. And if a doctor thinks subscribing fat burning pills and liposuction to a girl with the condition, the parent should be outraged rather than" supportive".

reply

"the parent should be outraged rather than" supportive".

sorry I view what society could be than what it is Old Ideals need to die , clearly your afraid of Idealistic Change

reply

What? Your writing is indecipherable.

reply

Glad it's not just me. This thread is giving me a migraine. Hard to give credence to someone who can't form a sentence.

reply

Cutting parts of your body and mutilating yourself is in my book mental illness…

reply

No. Opposing some one's choice on how they want to look and feel is mental illness. That's right! You have PERMANENT mental illness.

reply

Proof?

reply

The problem is that not too many people oppose that. Do whatever your insanity asks you to do as long as it doesn't involve me.

The problem is when YOUR insanity insists on forcing ME to accept it.

Are you insane and you think you are the opposite gender? I DON'T GIVE A FUCK.

But don't come and force YOUR mental illness on me and FORCE me to accept that you are something you are NOT.

Keep your fantasy and insanity for yourself. I'm NOT interested.

reply

WE are not forcing our views on you. It's the other way round. You bigots are the ones preventing gender-affirming care to be administered. Let trans people do what they want to. Why are YOU stopping them? Any answers? No, it seems. You lose.

reply

Who's more mentally ill, the tranny or the doctor who did it?

reply

The doctor is just greedy, not insane. He just made few thousands dollars, he is the smart one ...

reply

Anyone willing to mutilate a child and it doesn't do what they promised it should do, is pretty fucking sick in the head. Trying to make money off that is like getting paid to be a serial killer.

reply

Let THEM do what they want to. It's their life. Mind your own fucking business, you bigot.

reply

Idiot. they can do whatever the fuck they want with THEIR life, NOT with the life of others (kids as an example).

reply

its not people aren't comfortable with there assigned Gender at Birth that should be celebrate not revieled besides they are welcome to have a seat at the table as should everyone!

What?

reply

exactly

reply

Yes it is.

reply

no it isnt , your ignorance and insensitivity showing clearly not Educated

reply

Yes it is.

reply

Befus your clearly and Insenstive Bigot

reply

Joogle you're clearly a moron.

reply

No YOU are a moron Befus.

reply

Why because I refuse to live in your world of make believe?

reply

Because you're a bigot.

reply

Refusing to live in your world of make believe makes me a bigot? Ok. Don't care.

reply

A bigot cannot disqualify himself as a bigot based on his whims. Us rational people get to do so, and I'm sorry, but you do 100% qualify as a discriminator.

reply

Go ahead, keep living in your world of make believe. One day it will all come crashing down around you and reality will teach you it's hard lessons.

reply

there people just like you and I befus not crazies

reply

I never said they weren't people. They're just crazy people.

reply

They're just crazy people.

there not crazy people just people quit using labels to "Justify" your Ignorance and bigotry , Major Psychologists haven't listed as "Mental Illness" because IT ISNT

reply

They are crazy. If you're a man who thinks you're a woman or vice versa, you're crazy. Nothing is ever going to change that. People aren't "assigned a gender at birth". You are what you're born as. If you're born a man, you'll die a man. If you're born a woman, you'll die a woman. No matter how much you mangle your body along the way. There is no such thing as "born in the wrong body". We're all born in the one and only body we're ever going to get. If you could somehow rewind the universe and replay it a million times over, we'd still all be born in the same body.

People who can't accept this and think they can change what they are and always will be, ARE CRAZY.

reply

People who can't accept this and think they can change what they are and always will be, ARE CRAZY.


clearly your insensitive and bigotry you need change your thinking not them i know people who had sex changes there lovely people same people who date the opposite gender THEY ARE NOT CRAZY

reply

Yes they are.

reply

was declassified as A Mental Illness in 2012 its no longer the case therefore your "Theyre Crazy" Ideologue is Dated


https://nicic.gov/being-transgender-no-longer-mental-disorder-apa-2012#:~:text=Transgender%20people%20will%20now%20be,more%20than%2020%20years%20ago.

reply

I gave you facts Sex Change IS NOT A MENTAL ILLNESS



Being transgender no longer a 'mental disorder': APA (2012) why are using outdated information and insist its revlent



https://nicic.gov/being-transgender-no-longer-mental-disorder-apa-2012#:~:text=Transgender%20people%20will%20now%20be,more%20than%2020%20years%20ago.

reply

You seem to think that just because a bunch of people with a political agenda changed a definition, that means crazy people are no longer crazy. Well guess what? It doesn't. They're still crazy.

reply

if your party care about at ALL about Human Rights you wouldn't be disagreeing therefore makes your Party(Whos Agenda is too Keep Marginalized, Marginalized) please don't speak of Equality also your not A Psychologist

reply

I don't have a party. They're both retarded.

reply

your retarded for thinking there crazy and your neutrality doesn't make you scott makes and ignorant bigot and you have chosen the side the side of the Oppressor YOU BIGOTED COWARD FUCKFACE

reply

I can't even tell what you're saying. Learn to spell.

reply

Joogle83: yes it is, you ignorant bigot. Your opinions are insane, and you should be as ashamed of yourself as your parents must be.

reply

nice try my late dad was hard right Conservative christian Nationalist like Krato's in the New GOW Games im choosing to be better my mom is supportive of marginalized people unlike my late father your parents should be ashamed be better .

reply

Whoever tried to teach you to write coherently, should be ashamed of themselves. Go back to school.

reply

How do you imagine beeing a loonie leftard make you better?🤣

reply

What education is there on this? Do you have a pamphlet? There are no long term studies. This is new. You're parroting shit you hear from other retards, which resonate with you because you're one too.

reply

If a 6'5" heavily-muscled hairy strong male body-builder suddenly announced that he wanted to have radical surgery to remove most of his muscle mass, chemically remove all his body hair, have his vocal cords surgically altered so that he could only speak in a high pitch, take steroids to decrease his bone mass, and have his body fat redistributed and implanted on his ass and hips, you'd call him crazy, right?

If you don't think that's a mental illness, then you don't know what mental illness is.

reply

ITS NOT sex change isnt listed under major mental illness' according to psychologists . you conservatives put a label on everything because you FEAR it as a threat to your livelihood IT.IS.NOT

reply

I'll bet your Mommy doesn't know you're using her computer.

reply

Im using a Laptop i bought

reply

Does your momma know that you used her CC?

reply

There is no such thing as a "sex change". Just freak-show surgery. If you truly believe a "trans-woman" is a woman, then go have sex with one.

reply

yes sex change is a thing and Conversion Therapy is Inhumane

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/what-is-gay-conversion-therapy

reply

Joogle83: ok, so gay conversion therapy didnt work out for you. That doesnt mean that you somehow can magicly become a woman.

reply

ok, so gay conversion therapy didnt work out for you. That doesnt mean that you somehow can magicly become a woman.
im not a woman i am Ally of LGBTQIA im a straight male its not a crime to be straight and stilll support LGBTQIA+ Community a place exists were Outdoorsman and LGBTQIA+ Live in Harmony its called Colorado.

reply

Have you felt this way ever since beeing NAMBLA's little playthingy?

reply

no, it's not.

You CANNOT change your sex. Period.

You can CUT your sex and add some ... toys, plastic, etc. But ... those are NOT sex organs. Period.

reply

Somebody tell me this is a troll. If you are trying to sound intelligent please get your grammar and spelling right!

Here's my favourite entry: -
[–] Joogle83 (3079) 2 months ago
no it isnt , your ignorance and insensitivity showing clearly not Educated

reply

Seems like a troll. I love it when it's difficult to tell, makes it even funnier.

reply

Since when was anyone uncomfortable with their gender at birth?

reply

People are not "assigned" gender at birth. They factually, biologically are either male or female at birth. Later on, if they don't like that and are willing to dress up as the other gender, and drastically alter themselves with drugs and surgery, they are absolutely mentally ill, and should be protected from themselves, and from all the quack psychologists and doctors who play along with the lunacy.

And don't give me that crap that sex and gender are not the same thing. Up until very recently, gender was nothing more than a synonym for sex. Any pre-woke dictionary will confirm that. The idea that gender is something else is an illiterate, unscientific woke social construct.

reply

"Gender is not sex! That's why me as a transgender will go for gender reassignment surgery (which is nothing else than a sad attempt (and failed) to switch to the opposite SEX)."

reply

What counts as "mental illness" to you?

In any case, it barely matters what it means in clinical standards. Most people who accuse it do so with a broad definition in mind.

Advocates who deny it to be a "mental illness", can't escape from describing it as delusional, fanatical, suicidal, and a whole slew of other unhealthy things.

reply

Just like a weirdo and psycho can't be ill enough to be mentally ill, a lefty can't go left enough to be insane. They don't see it because they are INSANE. So insane, THEY HATE NORMAL BEHAVIOR. It comes off as flaunting a healthy lifestyle.

reply