MovieChat Forums > The Irishman (2019) Discussion > I'm just curious....if you could have ca...

I'm just curious....if you could have cast younger actors to portray De Niro, Pesci and Pacino, who?


If you could have cast younger actors to portray the earlier lives of the three main characters, who would they have been?

reply

Maybe Adrian Brody as Pacino?

reply

Pacino does not look like Hoffa and Adrian definitely doesn't look like Hoffa.

reply

The thread is about the actors though, not the real life characters.

reply

I agree that the thread is about the actors and not the characters they play.

On the other hand though, I also think that the casting directors should at least try to make an effort to cast someone who looks like their character.

That aside, I think Gary Oldman might have been a good Jimmy Hoffa. He doesn't really look a lot like him a ton though, maybe if he gained a bit of weight beforehand?

I think the "de-aging" technology is kind of interesting and would be cool for little flashback scenes here and there. To use it for like 1/3rd of the film was a little much though, especially since it's still in its infancy and has a lot of kinks to be ironed out.

De Niro still moved like an old man and it was obvious that he's not the young lad he was billed to play. (Also, De Niro is what, 5'10"? Sheeran was what, 6'4"-6'5"?)

I think with the "young" characters having such a significant amount of screentime, that they should have given the part(s) to a younger generation though.

reply

Digging up Burt Lancaster, Jimmy Cagney and Bogart would have looked better.

reply

Liam Neeson would have been perfect as Sheeran,

reply

You are totally correct. DeNiro was good, but miscast in the role.

reply

L.Neeson(de-aged) as Sheeran
S.Graham(Tony Pro) as Hoffa
Andy Garcia or John Leguizamo(aged) as Buffalino

De Niro was too old for the part maybe 20 years ago he would have been better and more convincing

reply

Not bad at all. A+.

reply

If you’re talking about actors nowadays, I have Oscar Isaac in mind to play younger Pacino as he’s always reminded me of Andy Garcia.

For Robert De Niro, I can’t find anyone. He has a unique face, but he’s easy to do an impression of him so anyone who has similar features to him and can do a mean impression would work.

reply

Nah, I was talking about this particular movie.....what actors would have been good as the younger versions with De Niro, Pesci and Pacino being the older parts but with younger actors in the earlier parts....

reply

Zack Efron, harry styles, and Nick Jonas

reply

I love the selling point of having DeNiro, Pacino and Pesci in a movie together again, but If the film was going in a different direction I would have picked Alan Arkin to play Hoffa. Not a younger actor but I think he looks a lot like the real man, and he can act.

reply