MovieChat Forums > Timothy Dalton Discussion > Which James Bond is Better? Roger Moore ...

Which James Bond is Better? Roger Moore or Timothy Dalton?


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mYTzC1gMwNA

I compare the two James Bonds of the '70s and '80s, one known for his wild adventures and the other for his more serious tone.

reply

What feels better? A massage or surgery without anesthesia?

reply

Ridiculous question.

Quite obviously Sir Roger. He played the part seven times (the most often in the original pre Craig series). Dalton on the other hand, presided over the of the lowest grossing Bond films of all time and was largely disliked by the public at the time.

A better, more interesting question would be to question the tenures of Sir Roger vs Connery.

reply

Roger Moore was a kind of campy James Bond, an effeminate jokey guy. I thought Dalton did a good job, and liked his movie better, I still remember that car chase around Gibralter ... at least I think I do. Moore's Bond movies were like cartoons.
Craig's were pretty good, but that pointless disgusting ball smacking scene grossed me out of the Bond genre.

reply

Moore was good at what he did but I prefer Dalton's broodier and more cold blooded approach so I will go with him.

reply

This, exactly.

reply

Definitely Dalton. Moore seemed more like a game show host.

reply

This.

reply

Dalton but it's hard not to like Roger Moore.

reply

👍

reply

I like both, Moore was 007 in several movies, so in this way you have more chances to have "great moments " as James Bond. Dalton was only in two movies, he did it well.

reply

I think I'm mostly in alignment here. I like both, although I do prefer Dalton's portrayal.

Basically, I feel like Dalton was a better Bond, but because Moore isn't trying to do that - he's trying for dapper and quippy, not the gentleman-thug that "pure Bond" is - I can't really fault his performance because they don't have the same goal.

And your last point I will echo entirely: with seven films, Moore participated in some wonderful Bond adventures, so even though I'm not as big a fan of his Bond, I am a big fan of The Spy Who Loved Me, For Your Eyes Only, and Live and Let Die.

Although, let the record show that I think Licence to Kill is one of the most underrated Bond films of all-time (along with The World is Not Enough).

reply

Moore, no contest. Moore is still the solid number two Bond, after Connery, and probably always will be since they seem to be getting worse and worse.

reply

Moore turned charm to the max and he is a legend. Not as good as Craig as a ruthless killer, but they are both excellent in their own way. Connery's era was before I was born, so he has remained a little more distant to me. These are the three greats, the rest deserve no mentioning.

reply