MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > What punishment should this thug get for...

What punishment should this thug get for punching the teacher?


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11bs9FrdTVM&t=63s I'm calling him a thug because only thugs react violently to accidents.

reply

Clapping the chalky erasers out back after school.


[none]

reply

Blood Eagle seems appropriate

reply

A one month stint at boot camp.

reply

He shouldn't have punched her but I need more context.

reply

Yeah. Why was the door slammed? Did she really know his arm was there? Was it an accident? Was there a confrontation with the person who's arm was in the door? It's so hard to tell from that short clip.

reply

I watch it in slow motion, there is another kid on the outside holding the other side of the door, and that is the one the teacher seems to be exchanging words with. It seems like they got him to to back off and the teacher tries to quickly slam the door. The students hand is not in the door initially, but it looks like he leans in to say something to the other kid, and his back hand naturally extends back, and in to the door.

So I don’t think she did it intentionally, and I don’t think he was initially doing anything wrong. He may have been a bystander, or a peacekeeper.

But it still doesn’t justify punching a teacher imo.

reply

Thank you, Mr Crisp.

reply

A FAIR TRIAL.

reply

^

reply

100 lines, ‘I must not punch the teacher’.

reply

And if he escapes and receives none, would that really be a terrible tragedy? What about if 20 years pass from today?

reply