MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Do you give money to homeless people who...

Do you give money to homeless people who beg?


I’m kind of on the fence about this because on the one hand I can be totally sympathetic to someone being in a desperate situation and I can’t possibly understand what it’s like not to have food but at the same time I am often nervous about doing this because A) when I give them the money they could easily pull a knife out on me or B) they could just go and spend the money on drugs which means by giving them money I am harming them.

reply

I do. I don't get all uppity about what they spend it on, either.

reply

This exactly. If I was homeless I'd want to get drunk or high too.

reply

No. I give to animal charities instead. A human can do sonneting to help themself. A domesticated animal cannot. (I also give to a few wildlife rescue/rehab charities.)

reply

Respect that. I do too. I support wild animal sanctuaries that protect endangered animals from poachers and habitat destruction.

For people, I do give when I have paper money to spare, but I rarely carry cash anymore. Instead, I donate to local food pantries and work centers. I volunteer to help out when I can too.

reply

👍

reply

yep. i've been homeless. I usually keep spare bux in my pocket. I don't ever pull out my wallet in front of anybody.

reply

With bloodshot77 and the panhandlers it worked well. ☻
The question and thread. ☻☻

reply

When I was in SF, I saw a guy give this woman change, and I remember turning around and giving her change. She said, "I might be able to get a cup of coffee with this" and then I asked if she wanted to have a cup of coffee. We did, walked, talked, and then to a Chinese restaurant before she parted ways.

reply

Gotcha well that’s good you did that. My only concern about taking someone to give them lunch is I don’t know whether or not they are willing to mug me or something. I usually walk away when someone asks me for money or food because I’m concerned for my safety but at the same time I always feel horrible about myself afterwards

reply

If you have a bad feeling, go with your instincts. I figure if someone wanted to stab me, they could do it behind my back.

reply

That little chinese restaurant in SF was the best food I've ever got.
Looooong ago, and it was looking somewhat dubious.
But clean...and hopefully I didn't eat the dog from the beach. ☻

reply

(this jagoff)

reply

No, mostly because I don't carry cash on me these days and homeless people don't have a card machine.

reply

No because you don't know if they are really homeless.

reply

Not much anymore. If they want food and I'm going into a grocery store, I might offer to buy them a bag of potato chips or something. But no to money, change isn't spare.

reply