MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Should Cultural Appropriation be relabel...

Should Cultural Appropriation be relabelled as Cultural Appreciation?


That’s much nicer, right?

reply

as long as people don't make false claims to be of a certain race or ethnicity

reply

They're two different things imo. Getting a tattoo from a culture that isn't your own where tattooing is a closed practice is appropriation. Getting a henna tattoo by a South East Asian person is appreciation.

But given how blended and inspired fashion, art and design is, it's honestly hard to define what's what sometimes, so I think being open, asking questions and using common sense and kindness go a long way.

reply

Isn't that what it used to be called before all this Woke bullshit?

reply

‘Cultural Appropriation’ is a silly phrase, I’ll have no truck with a fool that uses a term like that.

Taking and using bits of other cultures that we admire is normal human behavior. WTH has gotten into some people these days? It’s all gotten very stupid.

I like your term much better👍

reply

“It’s all gotten very stupid”

I agree, and it all seems to work in only one direction.

reply

Yes, the constantly whining direction that cries like we should all care.

Claiming victim status has become a cottage industry for far too many ‘journalists’ but a lot of dummies buy into it.

The News is mostly nonsense, just give me the sports scores and weather reports, the rest of it is pretty far from my lawn.

The Irish, the Jews, the Italians, the gays, you name it…we all took our lumps and gave them all Hell right back.



reply

👍

reply

Well it does make a fuck of a lot more sense. I'd prefer though no label and people do whatever the fuck they want as long as it's legal.

reply

First world problems. It's just another fabricated concept, a tool for the 21st century liberal racist. People really need to get a life. What someone else wears or does with their hair is none of your fucking business.

reply

“What someone else wears or does with their hair is none of your fucking business.”

I never said it was.

reply

Did I say you did? No. You brought up "cultural appropriation". I gave my opinion.

reply

It was unclear who you were aiming your remark at. No worries 👍

reply

The crowd from the politics section are used to insulting one another. When they post here they forget their manners.

reply

No, we're just tired of this kind of bullshit.

reply

[deleted]

I have done a lot of thought on it over the years, trying to understand both sides. I think where it becomes an issue is if someone is taking something from someone's culture that isn't their's and monetising it. Like when they would sell the north american indigenous head dresses. Those have cultural and spiritual meaning. I work at living history museum that has an indigenous people's pavilion and since white people (meaning the church) pretty much tried to irradicate their culture, and really them, to then make money on their clothing seems really wrong to me.

I also think that there are a lot of people, mostly younger white people, who have some sort of guilt over situations like what I just mentioned and are screaming appropriation at anything and everything to feel better about themselves. If a culture offers to share their clothing or practices with others, it's not appropriation.

That being said, I don't think that appropriation applies to food, and I also don't think that it's unnatural. I mean isn't that how we evolved. We (humanity) traveled to other places, learned new things, and then brought what we liked, or what would benefit us home with us. So I do agree that in a lot of scenarios appreciation could 100% replace appropriation.

reply

I also understand when it comes to hair.

A lot of the "hairstyles" in question have meanings in the culture where they originated from. It could be marital status, social status, which tribe they belong to, what family in the tribe, and so on. It's very similar to the Indigenous headdresses. They have a deep meaning in that culture, and when someone takes something that has meaning that they don't understand and uses it as a fad or trend, it can be upsetting. Especially if those who's culture that "trend" comes from are looked down upon for having the same hairstyle, or clothing.

reply

But we are not the white people that did that. Am I responsible for my father's actions? No, no more than I am of that of my great, great, great grandfather. I know many white people who perpetuate the art and material culture of Native Americans. Myself included. Are we keeping an art form alive, doing something we love and appreciate or "appropriating"? Do I care what others think of it? Not really. If a Native American (or stupid white liberal) tells me I'm "appropriating" and that I should stop, am I going to stop or tell them to kiss my ass?

I just think this is a clever new way to perpetuate victimhood. Perpetrated by busy-bodies with nothing better to do than invent new ways of being offended.

reply

[deleted]