MovieChat Forums > The Lighthouse (2019) Discussion > I love a good lighthouse movie, but too ...

I love a good lighthouse movie, but too bad it was shot entirely in black and white


Shutter Island was a good lighthouse movie because it was shot entirely in color, not lousy black and white.

reply

I loved the black and white cinematography. It really suits The Lighthouse. I don't think it would have looked right in colour.

reply

Kind of like the way Schindler's List was shot in black and white, right?

reply

Right. Black and white really suits certain films.

reply

all black would have suited this one

reply

How 'bout if it was shot in blackface?

reply

Or "Roma" or "Cold War" or "The White Ribbon" or Guy Maddin's films or Béla Tarr's films or any number of contemporary films that choose black and white. There's usually a good reason. "The Lighthouse" in color is pretty unthinkable.

reply

Someone did a Google search for “black and white films”.

reply

Nope, sorry. My memory isn't that bad.

reply

black and white was crucial for the atmosphere and the ingmar bergman vibe the film was going for.

reply

The Light Between Oceans is a recent "lighthouse movie". There was another one, I forgot the name.

reply

The Vanishing with Gerad Butler and Peter Mullen may be the other lighthouse movie you were thinking of.

reply

No, that's not it. It's an indie movie I vaguely recall it's about a woman, very puritanically dressed, who takes over as lighthouse keeper after her husband dies and there is some drama about how lighthouse keepers are always men. It might not be recent now that I think about it. Maybe from the mid/late 2000's.

reply

[deleted]

I would love to see as many films in b/w as they're in color. Cinema needs some balance. It's one of the reasons why I watch films or listen to songs that are far from my taste, so when I get to things suited to my kind of taste it is more impactful. The same is true about genres, horror is never as good if there's no humour for instance, or action without drama, slow and fast pace inter-changing in one film. Contrast in life is important, in every aspect. However in this case I love b/w films, often more than color films, which sometimes can take away the magic of cinema.

reply

I loved the black-and-white. There's something very exciting about movies in black and white, especially when the director made the choice in a colour film world to make a movie in black and white.

The images in Manhattan are brought into sharp focus by the black and white, for instance, and really shows off a certain aspect to the story, characters, and themes of the movie.

The same applies here. The Lighthouse's black and white look enriches the claustrophobic, days-gone-by world of this film.

reply

who knew " lighthouse movie" was a thing!
Theres one in "The Rock" does that count?

reply

I thought the same thing lol. Never heard of that being a sub-genre, but I can dig it.

reply

That's just, like, your opinion, man.

reply

I thought the black and white gave it great atmosphere

reply