Leia was a Mary Sue in a New Hope


I know people like to think if they slap an insulting label on things, they have accomplished something and freed themselves of the inconvenience of considering anything deeper, but it's lazy and foolish.

reply

true, if people didn't follow the label with paragraphs of the reason why they think Rey was a Mary Sue I would think it was lazy as well.

You on the other hand simple stated it, and gave no reason why she may have been.

reply

^^^ Pretty much this

reply

You and butthole have missed the point. The OP was simply about guys using insulting labels.

reply

Yeah you're the one using the "Mary Sue" label as an excuse to ignore the arguments about how badly written Rey is.

Nobody is "afraid of strong women." Rey is a badly written character, that's it.

reply

Every "argument" I've seen is one of three things:

1. Constant repetition of "Rey is a Mary Sue" with no actual argument.

2. Attacking her solely because they feel she is more powerful than Luke, and contrasting her against him, implying that it would be "wrong."

3. Completely dismissing her character traits, given backstory, and onscreen activity in order to push an agenda that she was a helpless girl who could do nothing, thereby casting her actions as impossible, as well as dismissing all of her screw-ups in the movie in order to push an agenda of casting her as perfect and flawless.

All I've seen is dishonesty, anger, and OFTENTIMES extreme anti-female rhetoric from the "Mary Sue" crowd. They basically feel justified in attacking a fictional woman because a huge misogynist sex predator (Max Landis) popularized a term they can slap on her.

reply

I see. So you completely ignore all the given points that are given at each of thos threads. So you are just a useless fanatic which defends even the worst pile of sh*t.

reply

Lawrence Kasden wrote her so you can take that up with him.

Just because she doesn't conform to the flawed, weak, boy who struggles to overcome his flaws and triumphs, after assistance from old guys, heroes journey paradigm doesn't disminish Rey for me. I've seen that. I've seen flawed weak boy struggles and fails and gives into the temptation of the Darkside.

I love that Rey is smart, confident, capable, takes ownership of her own development and I'm excited to see where it goes. It's interesting to see what might happen if instead of what can the world do for the character, the character is already "evolved" and chooses to see what she can do for the world.

Some people aren't open to "different than I liked before". I get that.

reply

They're all just parroting one of the biggest douchebag misogynists in Hollywood, Max Landis, who popularized that term against Rey with his Twitter feed and kicked it all off (Max has actually said he regrets it, too, and deserves scrutiny -- He said this in October 2017 and I posted about him on the Force Awakens board, I can post the links here if you want).

Oh and Max is also an accused sexual predator, with many women backing up the accusations.

When you look at the "Rey is a Mary Sue" fad in that overall context, it makes all too much sense.

reply

Well I do feel there's an argument to be made that Rey is not a well written character and she would actually make a better female role model if she was more believable and better integrated into the Star Wars universe.

And I wish "Mary Sue" had never come into vogue because all it does is needlessly polarise the discussion and make it about misogyny and being afraid of strong women when the real point IMO is the bad writing.

reply

Get some sleep you drunken fool.

reply

Leia was a Mary Sue in a New Hope

Absolutely. Everybody knows that Leia mastered the Force in the first movie, no training required. She was even a better pilot than Luke, taught Chewbacca how to fix the Falcon and in her spare time gave some lessons to Han about smuggling. Not to say C3P-O used to call her asking for help every time he had problems to translate some language :)

reply

Evidence provided to back up your theory = none.

In a New Hope Leia was:
- Already a princess and an accomplished leader.
- Already a leader of the rebel alliance.
- Already battle hardened.
- Already trained.

So Leia just acted like who she was. She didn't use the force or do things out of character. She never single handedly saved the day, and only barely escaped death with Luke's help. And despite her strengths, she still needed to be rescued.

Contrast this with Rey - a nobody from nowhere with no training who becomes the most powerful Jedi in history in the span of a few weeks of "time" in the story. Over two movies Rey has never been hurt and never been in real danger and never needed help from anyone. That's a "Mary Sue."

The irony is that the Rey character is the one that portrays women in a worse light. She is not a real hero that girls can look up to, she's a fake a stereotype.

reply

Quite ironic that the SJW paragons of strong women in Hollywood can't get a single strong woman character to look real ^^

reply

If you can answer this riddle then I will never ever call Rey a Mary Sue again.

How did Rey know how to fly the Millenium Falcon?

reply

Do you only know how to drive one make and model of car?

reply

So Rey knew how to fly the Falcon because she had prior flight experience. What other ships did Rey fly in order to gain that knowledge?

reply

Who's to say,but if I see someone driving a car,I don't need to see them driving a pickup to assume they can.

reply

Thats true as well. But does the reverse apply to driving a car? Would you assume that a expert driver would know how to tear down a engine and rebuild it?

It was established in TFA that Rey is an expert mechanic. How does that translate into her being able to fly the Falcon and perform leet style stunts in order to evade 2 tie fighters?

reply

I see your point,but I would bet most expert car drivers are actually quite proficient mechanics. My guess is like Anakin, she has probably scavenged and repaired/rebuilt some type of crafts, and probably sold them to survive. I think like Luke,the Force let's her be a better pilot than her actual experience would normally allow,but her obvious strength with the Force gives her otherwise unnatural instincts and intuition.

reply

I get what you are saying but I think that only makes sense in a perfect world and we are talking about star wars here. In ANH, Biggs says that Luke is the best bush pilot in the outer rim territories also Luke says he used to target womp rats in his T-16. In TPM, Qui-Gon says that Anakin has the reflexes of a Jedi which is why he is the only human that can race in the Pod Races. I still can't come up with any information or exposition that explains Reys piloting skills. When Rey and Finn are running to the Falcon she says she has never flown it before and it hasn't flown in years.

reply

Ah, I was more showing the plausibility of it,and feel that the loops aren't closed that would make her a Mary Sue, but I completely agree that the lack exposition is there. Her character has too much unknown about it for sure. I feel it was intentional,and will get addressed in the final movie of the trilogy,but I don't think the writing was clean enough to pull of the mysterious background,if there is one. I think either way,with all of the fan backlash,there will be a SHITLOAD of backstory on her in the next movie. And multiple lightsaber battles too!

reply

I see. So you drive your motorbike extremely well. Thats a a good reason that you could drive each and every truck out there precise to the inch :) . Is it a condition for SJW to be plain stupid or is it just some accident?

reply

World of diference. yea she upstaged han solo a few times but the overall tone wasn't like rey.

reply