Going pretty good. How are you?
They could have done a similar thing to the first film, but I like what they did with it. I think they were able to engage with a larger story, showing a more gradual growth to Luke's character and his arc with Vader. I think they managed to get more out of it because of this. To wrap up those plot lines would be to have ESB end with the throne room scene, and that's the end of the trilogy. It becomes an mind-blowing, three-hour sequel (where they probably recover Han's body from Boba Fett in a space chase). Furthermore, the gap between ESB and RotJ lets us imagine Luke honing his Jedi skills, bringing him to the place he is at the beginning of the third film.
So, I agree that the plot threads aren't completed, but the arcs are, and here's the distinction I'm drawing:
Han and Leia spend the movie flirting and dancing around the love-hate they've got, but it's all (masterfully) unspoken. The tension is drawn out, and constantly jeopardized. First by their natural prickliness, later by 3PO interrupting, and then by Lando and Vader. While we don't get to see them together (dangling thread) we do hear them vocalize it. At the last second possible, Leia says she loves Han, and he confirms this in his inimitable style. The arc is complete (do they love each other?) even if the story continues (will they get back together!?)
With Luke, he's training to be a Jedi and confront Vader and avenge his father. His arc is frustrated by failure - all of his own impatience. He rushes his training, but he does confront Vader. Then, we get the curveball of all movie curveballs and the plot thread (Luke becomes a Jedi, avenges his father) becomes a new plot thread (Luke deals with the ramifications of the duel). He also, by sacrificing himself for his friends (and then by leaping from the catwalk), learns the true cost and discipline that Yoda was trying to teach him, rejects the Dark Side, and fulfills his destiny predicted in his cave failure. The arc (his impatience and self-obsession) is completed (he denies himself and rejects his father), even though the plot continues (he must deal with the consequences of his rushed confrontation with Vader).
reply
share