MovieChat Forums > Joker (2019) Discussion > Arthur Fleck won't be in the sequels (or...

Arthur Fleck won't be in the sequels (or any Batman movies) because...


...he's actually not the definitive Joker as we know, just an inspiration. His look and manners will be copycat by some other fucked up psycho.

According to that theory, Joaquin Phoenix is just a one-shot actor.

reply

Please not let the definitive Joker be Leto's.

reply

No definitive Joker....
We've had half a dozen at least.

reply

He definitely be in the bottom of the list don't worry about that. So many better takes on the character, Ledger's and Phoenix's are era defining.

reply

Nicholson's too.

reply

Nicholson's was Romero's for adults.

reply

Jack was playing Jack imo. Still very good. But Ledger and Phoenix were playing characters.

reply

But wasn't the Joker all in his mind, a bit like Tyler Durden from Fight Club in a way. You can see why Phoenix and Philips don't see it as a part of any universe from DC movies. I couldn't imagine Phoenix take on the character in Leto's Joker universe.

reply

With the DCEU dead it's not impossible that Pattinson will face off with Phoenix. Leto was apart of Affleck's Bat which is done.

reply

But Margot Robbie's Harley Quinn is also in Leto's Joker universe, and she's still not done.

Gadot's Wonder Woman and Momoa's Aquaman too are in Affleck's Bat universe, which means also connected to Leto's Joker.

Dang... DCEU is a mess. It's Frankenstein's monster of a franchise.

reply

Those movies are continuing but they will no longer be connected here forward.

reply

So you mean Pattinson's Batman would never meet Robbie's Harley Quinn, Gadot's Wonder Woman and Momoa's Aquaman?

I don't think so. Pattinson's Batman is probably still the same character as Affleck's Batman, just recast.

reply

The DCEU isn't dead, though. Aquaman 2, Suicide Squad 2, Birds of Prey, Shazam! 2, the upcoming Flash movie, and Wonder Woman 1984 all still take place in the same continuity.

reply

The individual films will continue with the same continuity but there are no plans for crossovers or stories spending across films with different characters. Basically think of it as a branching series starting at the same point but going off in vastly different directions.

reply

You are right on that. Maybe the phrase should be "The DCEU as we know it is dead, but the DCEU itself is still going forward."

reply

wouldnt mind a second joker movie to fill the gap to dark knight. he is definiely more interesting than batman

reply

This is sort of a cool idea. Have the Pattinson Batman in the same universe as Joker but have a different Joker.

reply

SPOILER ALERT




I assume you are speaking of the final twist of the movie where after Arthur is in custody, some random unknown guy in a clown mask pops up to killed Bruce Wayne's parents in the alley. Yes, that was very annoying because it means that you just pissed away 2 hours watching a movie about a guy that might have inspired Joker but the jokes on you the viewer because they don't actually show you who the real Joker actually is.

reply

Are you saying the guy who shot Bruce's parents was the real Joker? Because that would've been Joe Chill.

reply

It depends on which version of Bruce's parents murder you are talking about... the old comic version had Joe Chill killing them because he was hired by a mobster to kill Thomas Wayne... The later Tim Burton movie has the Joker killing his parents... In this movie neither is the one that kills them it is just some random Arthur Fleck fan. So I guess you can just chalk this up to yet another version of who killed the Waynes. So whether you want to go with the old 1939 version where the murderer turns out to be a hit man named Joe Chill or you prefer the Tim Burton Joker did it, doesn't really matter because in this movie neither one is the trigger man.

reply

How do we know it's not Joe Chill though?

reply

Joe Chill doesn't wear a clown mask.

reply

Joker also doesn't typically wear red and yellow, but this is a different iteration.

reply

Phoenix's Joker color scheme resembles Romero's Joker.

reply

As far as the movies are concerned I think only the keaton batman series had joker as the canonical killer of bruce wayn's parents. 1

reply

I actually liked his take. The only thing that bothered me was Joker's follower killing Bruce Wayne's Parents. That's really the only reason I wouldn't want this movie to be canon. I was fine with the guy Jack Napier who would later become Joker killing Bruce's parents in Tim Burton's Batman but the way it was done in this movie bothered me.

reply