MovieChat Forums > Maniac (2018) Discussion > Maniac Is the Most Netflix-y Netflix Sho...

Maniac Is the Most Netflix-y Netflix Show Yet. In a Bad Way


This is the first item I read about Maniac. Don't see why it highly rated.

Seems like VR weird fantasy. The Cage and Space Odyssey did that 50 years ago.

Metascore is 76 and doesn't include this review. https://www.metacritic.com/tv/maniac-2018/critic-reviews

https://www.wired.com/story/netflix-manic-review/

But when the computer overseeing the experiments starts taking on human qualities—it doesn’t wear tennis shoes, but it does begin feeling depressed—Owen and Annie suddenly experience shared, subconscious-occupying fantasias.

It's at this point that Maniac becomes completely untethered, both from any sort of recognizable human behavior, and from whatever narrative ideas it may have been setting up early on (none which were particularly novel, but still). In one fantasy, Owen and Annie imagine themselves as a working-class '80s1 couple trying to rescue a prized lemur. In another, they're at-odds early-20th-century con-artists … hoping to steal an obscure Don Quixote-related artifact ... during a séance.

Maniac’s fantasies are thirsty for whimsy: This is a show that thinks the word "lemur" repeated over and over again in a Long Island accent is funny, and that "everything in life is, like, connected" is some kind of miraculous observation. The episode-long excursions also bring to mind the early days of Netflix's original-series efforts, when the streamer would throw tons of dollar bills—but seemingly no notes—at pricey indulgences like Marco Polo and The Get Down.

reply

So you don’t see why a show that you haven’t seen a single second of is highly rated because of one article?

reply

I saw it and I agree with this review. "Maniac" is a mess of a show.

reply

I actually liked it. It was weird and different than all the remakes and reboots that we are seeing currently.

reply

I saw it and completely disagree with the review.

I'm very picky about shows, and IMO this is the best new show I've seen in years!

Confusing at first yes, which may be why you thought it was a mess of a show. But it's meant to be confusing, and the humour in it is brilliant!

reply

Most people just want to be spoon fed. Thankfully, they occasionally throw a bone to those of us who don't!

reply

Great saying!

reply

Like Norsemen.

reply

Yeah - it seemed to be going ok, but now I got to the lemur episode and errr... bailed out. I'm sure it's all connected and shit, but it looked and felt like a definite filler.

reply

yup - that's exactly as far as i got too.

it's a mess - had some funny gags, but not worth the time.

reply