MovieChat Forums > Grand Theft Auto VI Discussion > GTA goes also racially woke

GTA goes also racially woke


The trailer shows dirty white people rolling around in mud while black women are twerking. Then a white man watering his lawn in a thong.

reply

Are you implying the fat self-degrading garbage human twerking on the car wasn't a negative portrayal and instead something positive?
And when did GTA not portray any race as terrible throughout the whole series?

reply

Negative portrayal would require commentary. The trailer presented its case without commentary, so nothing was negative nor positive -- it was just there. It was the opposite of the GTA V debut trailer, which absolutely did have a negative spin on certain cultural aspects associated with California.

reply

What sort of commentary do you need to understand that a fat black woman shamelessly twerking on a car, in public, like an unhinged crazy person is indeed a negative portrayal?
Just like the white dude in a thong watering his garden.

My point is, GTA does not differentiate, it shits on everyone equally and therefore it cannot be woke, by definition.

reply

What sort of commentary do you need to understand that a fat black woman shamelessly twerking on a car, in public, like an unhinged crazy person is indeed a negative portrayal?


https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/lizzo-beauty-standard-she-turns-122605823.html

My point is, GTA does not differentiate, it shits on everyone equally and therefore it cannot be woke, by definition.


It didn't do anything but portray content in its trailer. The media glorifies the exact kind of content that was in the trailer. GTA didn't make any comments or display anything to make the content seem negative, and Rockstar already confirmed they won't be "punching down" at "marginalised groups":
https://www.theloadout.com/gta-6/avoid-punch-down-jokes

reply

Again: You need "comment" to tell you that a woman acting completely unhinged and shameless is a bad thing, really? Then the problem is you, not the game or any media telling you what to think, or not.

reply

You need "comment" to tell you that a woman acting completely unhinged and shameless is a bad thing, really?

Rockstar apparently doesn't think so, and neither does the establishment media. In fact, normal people should see something like Cardi B and the "WAP" thing as unhinged and a shamelessly bad thing, but that's not how she's portrayed in the media, and there are millions of people who seem to align with the media's view on her degeneracy, calling it "empowering":
https://www.complex.com/music/a/brianna-holt/cardi-b-megan-thee-stallion-wap-essay

So how are you of the mind that Rockstar is actually mocking it and not supporting it when the establishment calls it empowering and nothing in the GTA VI trailer indicated otherwise?

reply

Because it is Rockstar?
Have you played ANY of their games?
The whole series is basically nothing but societal satire from start to finish, how are you unaware of this!?

reply

The whole series is basically nothing but societal satire from start to finish, how are you unaware of this!?

Because they said this....

"While the series is famous for its ‘no holds barred’ satirical humour, developers report the studio is now cautious not to “punch down” with jokes aimed at marginalised groups in light of how the political and social climate has changed since 2013. "

https://www.gamesindustry.biz/rockstar-devs-report-improvements-to-crunch-culture-and-a-gta-that-doesnt-punch-down

Let me put this into perspective for you what constitutes a "marginalised" group according to the terminally ill who work at media outlets:
https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/61782ecbf6567d12f08ba3b9/fb14179e-7c6a-4b88-8c22-034a4c5ff169/Marginalized+Groups-min+%281%29.png

According to the chart and what Rockstar said, that means that no, they did not intend to mock a fat black woman on a car because of where she sits on the progressive stack -- it would be considered "punching down".

reply

...and yet they did?
I don't see why you're so unwilling to accept this.

reply

he wants it to be the case, so he can have an excuse to keep complaining and continue to delude himself into thinking his obsessive view of race politics is the truth

reply

...and yet they did?


Where?

reply

It did seem like the majority of the people in the trailer were black. Look at the beach scene. It didn't look like the Miami Beach I was at in 2022.

reply

They have to pander.

reply

[deleted]

They are all drawn from real life - https://youtu.be/mtGWI1k0qhs

reply

people like you are so desperate to cry woke, you'll see it anywhere you look. pathetic

reply

Except that he’s right:

"While the series is famous for its ‘no holds barred’ satirical humour, developers report the studio is now cautious not to “punch down” with jokes aimed at marginalised groups in light of how the political and social climate has changed since 2013. "

https://www.gamesindustry.biz/rockstar-devs-report-improvements-to-crunch-culture-and-a-gta-that-doesnt-punch-down

reply

You guys need to get off this woke bs. I watched the trailer and it looks awesome!

It's just a game for God's sake.

reply

That’s not woke so much as it’s reflecting real life

reply

Y'know, a few of the things like that portrayed in the trailer were taken from actual "Florida Man" news stories...Because truth really is stranger than fiction!


These threads are utterly ridiculous! The term "woke" has been so tainted by RWNJ outrage that is has been rendered utterly and irrevocably meaningless...

reply

You’d like that but Woke has a very clear meaning and was originally coined by Wokists. Now that the ideology has become toxic in the eyes of the public, Wokies play this ‘the word is meaningless’ game. It’s so transparent.

reply

YOU GUYS SCREAM WOKE AT EVERY MOVIE,SHOW,GAME,WHATEVER THAT ISN'T 100% WHITE,STRAIGHT AND MANLY.


MEANINGLESS IS AN UNDERSTATEMENT AT THIS POINT.

reply

This basic bitch straw man is another common Woke tactic 👆🏻

reply

NO..IT'S THE TRUTH...THE FEW TIMES ANY OF YOU ACTUALLY DEFINE THIS WOKE BOOGEYMAN...YOUR DEFINITIONS ARE SLIGHT AND FOOLISH...AGENDA THIS,PROPAGANDA THAT....JUST NONSENSE...IF YOU WANT TO BE INTOLERANT...AT LEAST MAN UP ABOUT IT...BECAUSE THIS WOKE WOKE WOKE WOKE BULLSHIT IS ABSOLUTELY STUPID.



THIS THREAD IS ABOUT A VIDEO GAME...THAT APPARENTLY CAN NEVER HAVE A FEMALE LEAD CHARACTER....BECAUSE...????....WOKE?....GRAND THEFT AUTO IS A WHITE MAN'S GAME.

reply

Indeed, clearly CJ(one of the greatest video game protagonists of all time) was just some hoity-toity member of the Vinewood elite in blackface!

reply

I DON'T PLAY THESE GAMES...I ASSUME CJ IS A CHARACTER FROM THESE GAMES...SO PERHAPS GRAND THEFT AUTO IS JUST A MAN'S GAME ONLY...LEAVING WHITE AT THE DOOR.

reply

The only reason Florida seems to have more bizarre criminals than any other state is because Florida's freedom of information laws make it easier for journalists to obtain information about arrests from the police than in other states. Your state probably has just as many freaks as Florida, but they aren't as free to disclose the info on them.

reply