MovieChat Forums > 300 (2007) Discussion > Why should Muslims be offended over this...

Why should Muslims be offended over this movie?


After all, the Battle of Thermopylae happened CENTURIES before Islam EVEN EXISTED.

I don't get it.

reply

They were probably offended the blatant homosexual undertones expressed by the portrayal of Leonidas and his men. After all, it wasn't just the Athenians who were "boy lovers" as Leonidas falsely declares in a certain scene. Greek men often had childhood "boyfriends"

reply

I think it was mostly Persian countries like Iran and Iraq, they were offended that their predecessors were portrayed as some inhuman monsters lol. Nevermind the fact that this is a comic book adaptation and not a historical adaptation LOL.

reply

You are a h0m0 making stuff up Homosexuals were pariahs in Ancient Greece and it was punishable to attend schools & gymnasiums with minors

reply

Keep deflecting. The Greeks are documented as the OG gay groomers

reply

This is your dumbfuck libel no evidence on the contrary there are numerous documented instances of homosexuals being punished in Ancient Greece and especially in Athens go read Timarchus against Aeschines

reply

Oh STFU, you revisionist Twat.

reply

you suck horse

reply

You are the motherfuckin' revisionist H0M0

reply

[deleted]

I remember some of the controversy when this was released. Didn't even know it was based on real historical events/people.

I thought it was just a brainless action flick with a ton of slow-mo and CGI that just happened to be set in ancient Greece.

I personally never really saw anything offensive about it, but this was before the PC/SJW culture wars, so any controversy it might have had probably faded off rather quickly.

reply

Both 300 movies are based on true events. The Battle of Thermopylae 480 B.C. certainly happened and was very sad. It was necessary to prevent Xerxes from invading Greece. There was an old movie which you might prefer to watch. The 300 Spartans (1962).

reply

They wernt

reply

Muslims are offended by just about everything. That's why they and liberals are such fast friends.

reply

They shouldn't. It's an action movie.

The people who were offended by the film would complain about how the Persians were depicted as monstrous (literally and figuratively) people who practice slavery and are, generally, evil. They would also point out that the Spartans were depicted as freedom-loving people who fit a lot of American self-image stereotypes, despite the Spartans of that era also having slaves (Helots) and being just as "boy-lovey" as the Athenians.

Given that it was released in the Bush administration, it's not hard to see that they are perceiving the film as painting the Greeks (West/Americans) as patriotic badasses and leaving the Persians (East/Iran/Arab-Muslim World) to be the bad guys. The film has little "grey area", so it's not like the politics are painted as nuanced.

I think it's clear that the movie isn't trying to be historically accurate, and I think it's main goal is to be "cool" and have a lot of testosterone-driven sword-and-spear fights. Accusing the film of racism or "Islamophobia" is, in my opinion, being over-sensitive. At worst, it's in the same category as movies like The Patriot, where you roll your eyes a little at the too-good image of the Colonials vs. the too-bad image of the British, but you just enjoy the film for what it is and you move on.

reply

I still want 2 meet the spartans .

reply

This movie was great but wasn't history.

reply

The guy who wrote the graphic novel alluded to the dangers of Islam at the movie premiere, so the association was started with him.

reply