By "nutty", I mean episodes that have major inconsistencies and problems, or can even be almost laughable, but that you still love anyway! In broadcast order:
1. The Galileo Seven
2. Arena
3. The Alternative Factor
4. Wolf in the Fold
5. Return to Tomorrow
6. By Any Other Name
7. The Enterprise Incident
8. Elaan of Troyius
9. The Cloudminders
10. All our Yesterdays
I really liked The Galileo Seven. What was the inconsistency found in it?
shareThis where I would put A Piece of the Action
good list
shareI thought Catspaw was pretty nutty. I don't think it had any inconsistencies, but the whole "giant cat" bit was pretty laughable. I still enjoyed the episode though.
shareI agree with your assessment - maybe this could replace "Wolf in the Fold" on my original list.
shareThis is the only episode I can remember. So must have made an impact on 5 year old me.
shareActually there s avery big plot hole in "Catspaw", one which I think is the biggest and most obvious in all of TOS.
shareI would be interested in what inconsistencies and problems you see in these episodes. I'm not saying there aren't problems, but what are you seeing to call them nutty. Several seem quite solid to me.
share