Who was at fault here

Well, from where I'm sitting and I've watched it twice believe it or not, the black guy I suppose would be charged with Manslaughter.. I don't know any other way this could go??

That's a hard one. Could be called self defence .

I say no one is at fault for the actual death, but the black guy should not be found guilty of anything.

The white guy was bigger, holding him up against a post, and he feinted like he was going to swing. So the black guy swinging first could be argued as self defense. It's reasonable that he felt threatened in that situation, and acted to defend himself.

However he did swing on someone right next to the train tracks while a train was coming, so I can see him being charged for manslaughter. I can also hear someone saying "your going in" in the audio. I can't tell who it is, but if it's the black guy, it has to be a murder charge, because that would show it was intentional.

If the big white guy was the aggressor that led them to be clinched in the first place, there is zero chance the smaller black guy gets charged with anything in a place like Philadelphia. Zero chance

[laugh] All aboard!

Haven't watched.... is this a murder or death video?
I don't want to see that.

Is it a fake training video, or a movie or what?

That's tough. I mean it I can't see a charge above Manslaughter, but I think it would be difficult to get a jury to convict after watching the video so I don't know if I think he would even be charged.