MovieChat Forums > Lost in Space (2018) Discussion > Cold enough for water to freeze in secon...

Cold enough for water to freeze in seconds but still raining


How dumb is that?

reply

I thought I was the only one with that particular complaint.

reply

On a strange planet like this... Perhaps the freeze came from released freeze pockets underground and the rain from overheated volcano clouds from above.... I don’t know how far you are in the episodes but it becomes rather obvious that the freeze is quite local, and so not atmospheric (at least not primarily)

reply

I did think it odd, but I can overlook it because we really don't know anything about the planet or what sorts of weather patterns or various properties it might have. We really only know how Earth is, so I guess with a fictional planet they have some room to do things that may not seem possible here.

The thing that really seemed to be some sort of mistake was in episode 2 when super math genius mom is talking about how they traveled trillions of light years. I rewound (is that the right word for going backwards on a DVR?) and that was what she said.

reply

I quit the show after the 1st episode, but the universe is unfathomably huge. If we're accepting that traveling to worlds outside our galaxy is possible, then traveling trillions of light years doesn't seem like much of a stretch, depending on how they are achieving faster than light speeds.

reply

[deleted]

My issue with the trillions of light years is that the most recent measurement of the universe's size is only on the order of around 28 Billion light years across. So trillions of light years is impossible. Trillions of miles, yes. Billions of light years, yes. But Trillions of light years is just wrong. (a light year is around 6 trillion miles I believe). I don't have any issue with their travel speed, you can always sci-fi up some reason to travel FTL with wormholes, bending space etc.

reply

You can disregard what I said. I looked it up and the number I gave is only the size of the observable universe. Depending on a number of factors, some speculation has the universe much larger than just the observable part, possibly in the trillions of light years, so it is possible and I no longer have an issue with it. I’m so stupid! Stupid, stupid, stupid! And worthless! I’m never gonna amount to anything!

reply

You idiot....😂😂

reply

[deleted]

Fair point, and I don't recall. I assumed it was, and I would think that if it wasn't it would have been mentioned by one of the characters. They were breathing the air (I think).

reply

[deleted]

Yeah it's a dumb trope. It doesn't even have to a virus or bacteria. Just some fine particulate in the air that after you breathe it for long enough destroys your lungs.

reply

You just described Connecticut weather perfectly.

reply

I don't think it was rain, it was ice melted by the burning magnesium.

reply

That is exactly what "freezing rain" is; the rain falls as liquid and freezes when it hits land.

Freezing rain is the name given to rain maintained at temperatures below freezing by the ambient air mass that causes freezing on contact with surfaces. Unlike a mixture of rain and snow, ice pellets, or hail, freezing rain is made entirely of liquid droplets. The raindrops become supercooled while passing through a sub-freezing layer of air hundreds of meters above the ground, and then freeze upon impact with any surface they encounter, including the ground, trees, electrical wires, aircraft, and automobiles.

reply