MovieChat Forums > Twin Peaks: The Return (2017) Discussion > Through 4 episodes.......thumbs up or do...

Through 4 episodes.......thumbs up or down.


For those that watched all 4 so far. Which way are you leaning?

Happy with the new show or feeling kind of meh...

reply

Thumbs up!

reply

Up too...way up!!!

reply

Thumbs up, episode 4 was my favorite

reply

Thumbs up, but I think they lost a lot of potential new viewers with the first couple episodes. He should've started out with something more accessible just to get people going... then hit them later with the more surreal passages. But as a fan of the show, I liked it a lot and it got better and better as they reintroduced old characters.

reply

If he had done what he wanted in the start and not what everyone else (the network) had wanted then the original Twin Peaks would have lasted lots longer and would have been so much better!

David Lynch is one of a kind and it is best to let him do what he wants without interference and then you can look back on it at the end and say what they hell was that?

reply


When Umberto Eco wrote The Name of the Rose, he said it was on purpose that the introduction pages were so demanding for the reader. He did this to make sure that those who really wanted to read his book had the patience to get through the beginning. He compared this first reading by climbing a steep mountain. Those who had the strength and patience to climb all the way to the summit, would get their reward from there on. It may not sound completely true - all writers, musicians, filmmakers surely want as large an audience as possible? Still, I choose to believe that Umberto Eco really meant what he said. Season 3 of Twin Peaks may look something the same.

reply

Thumbs definitely up, with a foolish smile and a tie around my head!
There's been a precious long time since I had such a good time, and also felt so lost, terrified and disturbed at the same time.

reply

Two thumbs up for sure, (in that special way that only Albert and Gorden would know)....

reply

Clinking coffee mugs!

reply

And eating pie...

reply

Long may the Giant be with us!

reply

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

reply

Two thumbs melding into one gargantuan thumbs up. Hog heaven.

reply

Thumbs up.

reply

👍. I leave that up to your imagination, and knowledge of things arkane.

reply