MovieChat Forums > Rogue One (2016) Discussion > Is this a prequel or a sequel?

Is this a prequel or a sequel?


??

reply

Its a prequel to ANH and a sequel to ROTS, so its actually ep 4.

reply

I agree with this assessment.

reply

What kind of math is that? Star Wars has been labeled as Episode IV since it was rereleased in 1981, and Revenge of the Sith has been labeled as Episode III since it was released in 2005. An episode that is chronologically set between 3 and 4 would be 3.5, or three-point-whatever (3.x) if you want to leave room for future episodes set between 3 and 4.

reply

Chronologically speaking its Ep IV. But that will soon change with the release of the new prequel, The Han Solo Story.

reply

No. There are infinite numbers between 3 and 4 (and there are infinite numbers in general, for that matter). Star Wars (1977) was established as episode 4 in 1981, and Revenge of the Sith was established as episode 3 in 2005. An episode that takes place between 3 and 4 is episode 3.x. It can't be episode 4 because there already exists an episode 4, obviously.

reply

This proves my point that you don't go inserting movies into a already established timeline. Its just stupid.

reply

Agreed and RO is episode 4 no matter how you slice it.

reply

Yup, pretty much, thanks disney for ruining star wars...

reply

Well I guess technically it both. It is a prequel to the original 1977 Stars Wars, now know as Episode IV:A New Hope. It ends immediately before A New Hope begins.
Which also makes it a sequel to Episode III.

reply


Well okay then. Thanks.

reply

Yes, of course it is!

reply

Its Episode IV.

reply

It fits both categories.

reply

It is a requel.

reply

haha, nice!

reply

It's a cash grab.

reply

It's the best Star Wars thus far.

reply

What are you smoking? I guess you never saw a New Hope or The Empire Strikes back. lol.

reply

Sure did. They weren't as good.

reply

It's not a sequel nor a prequel, it's a standalone spinoff.

The "episodes" are the Skywalker family story and this one is Jyn Erso's.

reply

That’s how I saw it. It’s just a story in the Star Wars universe.

reply