MovieChat Forums > West Side Story (2021) Discussion > There's no audience for this movie.

There's no audience for this movie.


Billie Eilish was on the Jimmy Kimmel show and quizzed on 1980s pop-culture. She didn't know what a Cabbage Patch Kid was.

You really can't blame her. When you look at all the entertainment options that are available today, young people can't keep up with everything from their own generation let alone be familiar with material from previous generations. Just look at all the TV shows made for kids on Netflix or Amazon Prime. There's more than you can shake a stick at. There's more video games than anyone has even heard of. The same is true for music. It's overload.

When young people today barely know the stuff from their own generation, they're not going to be actively looking at what their parents and grandparents watched. Only juggernauts like Star Wars will a reboot ever have a chance, and that's because the nostalgia targets a demographic that still goes to see movies (Generation X), so their interest might ignite interest in the younger generations and bring the franchise back to life.

West Side Story came out in 1961, so who's nostalgic for it? It would have to be people who today are in their 70s. These people don't go see movies anymore, just like they're not targeted in advertisements by marketers (sadly) for products other than drugs. If they don't go see the movie, then there won't be any buzz about it that will ignite interest in other demographics.


reply

I'm 62. Saw it today - only.one other person in and he was older than me!

reply

I agree. I knew this movie was doomed for failure when I first heard about it. I remember thinking, "Whose gonna go see this." I went to see this movie because my 14yr-old niece wanted me to take her. She likes musicals. But there's not enough of her kind to make this movie float, and not enough old-heads that wanna go see it.

reply

Lots of dumb generalizations.

reply

I saw it today. I never ever thought I would say this but, this movie is BETTER than the original. Ansel is the most glorious Tony and this young actress puts Natalie Wood to shame as Maria. The actor who played Bernardo is awesome as are many of the ancillary actors.

I recognize several dancers from So You Think You Can Dance, Jess LoProtto being one of them. The dancing in this is far superior to the original. I'm seeing it again in two days and this time I'm taking my husband to see it.

reply

I'm glad you enjoyed it and gave an unbiased review! Sometimes movies are good without people knowing it!

reply


My sister in law saw it and said it "stunk on ice". I guess she should have gone to the Ice Capades reunion instead.

reply

Hehe! I guess she really didn't like the reboot/remake of the film version of West Side Story very much. As a devout fan of the old, original 1961 film version of West Side Story who not only saw both trailers and extra photographs and who also saw parts of the reboot/remake of the film version of WSS on a TV program not that long ago, which emphasized comparisons between the old, original 1961 film version of WSS, and Spielberg's reboot/remake of the WSS film version, and who also listened the entire soundtrack of the reboot/remake of the film version of WestSide Story on youtube, and didn't like what I saw/heard, I could NOT agree with your sister-in-law more. I get a good idea of whether or not I'll like a movie enough to go and see it by seeing one or two online trailers, previews, or photos.

Also, the soundtrack of West Side Story 2021 was very metallic sounding, Rachel Zegler's singing voice was very nasal in a lot of places, Ansel Elgort's acting and singing is overrated, and the movie itself seems way overdone. The stuff about Ansel Elgoft grooming and sexually assaulting underaged girls also turned me off to seeing it, and I'm voting my pocketbook, and not seeing it, at all. I've always had a gut reaction against reboots/remakes of older classic films, especially something like West Side Story.

reply

I think about this topic a lot. Of how little people seem to know about the history of pop culture. It seems so odd and kinda depressing to me. Because, when you think about it, this is probably the first generation who grew up not knowing who Lucille Ball was since I Love Lucy first came out. Because from the moment in premiered up until around the early 2000's, we all only had a limited amount of channels to choose from. And we were all forced to watch the classics due simply to having no other option but old reruns sometimes. I remember, as a kid, thinking it was kinda interesting that -- at least when it came to these old shows -- every generation of my family was on the same page. We all knew what "One of these days, to the moon!" meant, or who Meathead was, and we all knew that two thumbs up and a "Heyyyyy" was in reference to the Fonz. I wasn't even born when these things aired. But they were all nevertheless one of pretty much everyone's (nationwide, if not around the globe) few shared, fun commonalities. Regardless of age, race, politics, or where you were from.

As great as it is to have a plethora of choices that you can access at any point, it feels almost pointless if you've got no good direction on which things to pay attention to and learn about. It's like having a high IQ but having no teachers to guide you on how to think. We've got no Siskel and Ebert that we're all simultaneously watching, telling us a weekly lineup of all the new good movies that are out. We've got no TV series that everyone is watching at the same time and talking about (Game of Thrones was the last thing we got close to that with, I think). It's all very isolating. Like we're all living in our own individual customized bubbles, no longer sharing anything together (on such a large scale) anymore.

I know this is all just a big digression having nothing to do with West Side Story, but your post got me thinking about it, haha. Sorry.

reply

My wife looks at me funny when I hum all the tunes to 70’s TV shows verbatim. She grew up outside Western culture and had no clue about Michael Jackson or Buck Rogers or Star Wars until I introduced her. Muscials bore her. Me, on the other hand, I love Fred Astaire films.

I find the original West Side Story to be pretty radical stuff, musical-wise, since I grew up watching old RkO and war-era MGM musicals. I don’t mind weird or expiermental musicals (loved Hedwig and the Angry Inch, Tommy, Xanadu).

I would probably be the target audience for the Spielberg film, but I don’t care about it. That’s sad, since if a sample of the target audience doesn’t care, then who enough out there does?

reply

I, too like a lot of the older movies, especially those of the 1960's better, especially the old, original 1961 film version of West Side Story, which is my all time favorite movie hands down. I've seen parts of the reboot/remake of the film version of WSS, and have heard the soundtrack on youtube, and it sounds metallic and tinny, and flat in many places. The singing voices of the leads in the reboot/remake of the film WSS were overrated, as well.

reply

What's really scary about this generation is I've seen several instances of kids around age 10 who can't communicate. I first thought they were taught not to talk around strangers but then I ran into a woman at a store, we struck up a conversation(haha) and then she brought up on her own that kids can't talk nowadays, probably because their parents let tablets, smartphones act as their babysitters.

reply

I think that Spielberg and Tony Kushner were hoping to appeal to a younger generation of kids, especially middle school and high school kids. Unfortunately, it hasn't worked. The fact that it's not doing well in the box office is a good indication of that.

reply

Entertainment options? All the music sounds the same. It's all crap if you ask me. At least West Side Story sounds like music and not something from outer space.

reply

That's the danger of advanced technology. It's sad, really.

reply

Hi, Modica.
I recently listened to the soundtrack of Spielberg's reboot/remake of the film version of West Side Story, on youtube, just out of curiosity, and it was very metallic-sounding and flat in a number of places. I also thought that the singing voices of Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler (who played the leads of Tony and Maria in Spielberg's remake of the film version of WSS) were too far back, and not forward enough. Zegler also went flat on a lot of the high notes, too, and she doesn't seem to have any control over her voice, either.

reply

I knew it wasn't going to be too great. Not sure why Spielberg thought this remake was a good idea.

reply

I didn't think the reboot/remake of the film version would be very good, either. It had been Spielberg's dream since he was a kid, which is why he thought it was a great idea.

reply

Hi again, modica. I've always had a gut reaction against reboots/remakes of great older classic films, especially something such as West Side Story. As a devout fan of the old, original 1961 film version of West Side Story, i've seen enough parts of Spielberg's reboot/remake of the film West Side Story, and listened to the entire soundtrack of West Side Story 2021 on YouTube, just out for curiosity, and heard enough about the stuff regarding Ansel Elgort, which made me decide to vote my pocketbook and not go to see the new West Side Story, at all.

I'll also add that the soundtrack to the new West Side Story is very metallic sounding, and Rachel Zegler's singing voice is quite nasal in many places, and Ansel Elgort's singing voice and acting ability is overrated. The whole thing feels totally forced, unnatural, and not at all like West Side Story to me, at all.

reply

This is more about education. "West Side Story" is a classic and it should be taught in high school drama, if not English.

Obviously a 19 year old will have no hands-on familiarity with cultural items of the past. That's why we have schools. Cabbage Patch dolls are something I wouldn't expect or want schools to teach about. They were godawful ugly. But important plays in history? That's part of a basic education in literature.

reply

Yeah, I'm not sure why knowing about Cabbage Patch Kids would be some kind of benchmark or civilization health. Beethoven or Shakespeare, sure, but Cabbage Patch Kids?

reply

I'd like to forget they ever existed. Lol.

reply

Now, the GARBAGE PAIL kids, on the other hand, that's another story.

reply

That's some low class stuff.

reply

I remember the Cabbage Patch Doll popularity. It was rather sickening, especially since they're rather ugly-looking anyhow, and people were getting into fights, both verbal and physical, over them, while waiting in line to get them, and one person even ended up with a broken leg, as a result. It was crazy!

reply