MovieChat Forums > Queen Cleopatra (2023) Discussion > White actors always played Jesus, hypocr...

White actors always played Jesus, hypocritical?


Now the ''anti-woke'' brigade are crying into their Trump manuals because it's happening in reverse (which I find annoying anyway, btw). Lol

reply

Jesus was Jewish, many Jews have light skin and can pass for white. More recent portrayals have shown Jesus with tanned skin and nobody complained, not even the "anti-woke brigade".

Cleopatra was not sub-saharan African, and therefore not even remotely black. At best she might have had tanned skin, but it's not a stretch for her to have light skin, or wearing make-up that gave her a light-skinned appearance.

reply

I doubt many Middle Eastern, Sephardic Jews of the time could pass for white.

reply

I don't doubt at all that many could. Look at Danny Thomas, the entertainer and founder of Saint Jude's Children's Research Hospital. He was born Amos Muzyad Yaqoob Kairouz. He was born in Deerfield, Michigan, but both his parents were immigrants from Lebanon. They were Maronite Catholics, not Jewish, but Thomas looked very much like Christians, Jews, and Muslims from that part of the Middle East, and the population has not changed that much genetically since ancient times.

Thomas had light olive skin, black hair, and facial features common to Middle Easterners, but still, he fit right in in 1950s America, when close to 90% of the country was still white. He didn't look like a WASP, but his appearance wasn't that different either.

reply

I think a lot of people, if they had to guess, would have thought -- because of the lightness of his skin -- that he was Ashkenazi Jewish. Or, perhaps, like Mike Conners, the fellow who played Mannix, Armenian. Danny Thomas looked "exotic," but you couldn't really nail him down. Sort of like Judge Jeanine, if my spellchecker has that right.

I'd always had the impression that Sephardic Jews were darker. Not black, but more café au lait. I could be wrong.

reply

Yes. And it's stupid to have any actor play Jesus in a barely based on the Bible Hollywood production with a lot of made up fake stuff. Those movies are anathema to me.

reply

OK just imagine that someone made a documentary about Barack Obama and cast a white actor, you would be pissing your pants in an outrage.

And we don't care about the race swapping, we care about the double standard. If you cast a white actor in a traditionally black role then it's "white washing", but if it's the other way around you are racist for having a problem with it.

reply

Jesus being a God has always been depicted to be relatable to various cultures.
He initially looked like a Roman - clean-shaved and dressed in a toga.
He is often black in Africa, asian in Asian cultures etc.

Besides he is not real and you can't compare a supposed "documentary" about a historical woman to a mythical creature.

reply

Mythical creature!?

"Virtually all scholars of antiquity agree that Jesus was a historical figure and consider the idea that he may not have existed at all to be a FRINGE theory."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus

reply

I'm still waiting for the Mansa Musa biopic, with the titular role going suitably to a black actor, but maybe it would cost too much.

reply