Terrible score


It was the just the constant BWAM thing over and over with other droning noise. The score for the 1984 by Toto and Brian Eno was way better

reply

I am shocked this criticism isn't mentioned a lot more. Hans Zimmer's score was absolutely dreadful. He has become a complete caricature of himself. I have no idea how they approved that score. Most of it never fit the scenes. It didn't matter if it was a battle sequence or a discussion, the musical score (or more appropriately, the musical noise) was always dowtrodden and somber. It made the film feel heartless and sterile. It needed a better composer to actually create a distinguishable score. Characters should have identifiable themes.

reply

Completely agree.

reply

I thought his score was decent, and that's coming from someone who HASN'T liked Hans Zimmer since he became Christopher Nolan's yes-man.

The score seemed to work well enough to carry the film and convey an "other worldly" sense that these events are occurring thousands of years in the future. I swear I also heard him cleverly hint as the theme from the 1984 Dune in one of the scenes. It was like a tip-of-the-hat motif.

That being said the prefer the score of the '84 film. But I did LOVE the 2021 Dune trailers finally using Pink Floyd music in a Dune movie.

reply

Also there was something wrong with the mastering. Ok it was made for the cinema, but the center (voice) was so quitet compared to the explosions and music I had to adjust the volume all the time to keep things low.

reply

Yeah. My one complaint really is Zimmer's score. Zimmer has been incredibly overrated since TDK. His Batman Begins score was good but everything since, yikes. This isn't the Gladiator Hans Zimmer anymore and hasn't been for a long time.

reply

I had a really hard time hearing the music over all the noise in the film, and the few times I could hear it, it sounded like banging keyboard keys, or screaming voices, or it blended too much with the sound-effects to tell there was a rhythm at all.

My brother listened to the soundtrack, and he says there is music, but again, someone made a crappy decision to blend it in with the sound in the film. What's sad is, this particular composer is supposed to be one of the best in the movie business alongside the likes of John Williams and Dani Elfman.

reply

The 1984 main theme is better. The new Zimmer score opts for building an atmosphere, soundscape. Same as Zimmers Blade Runner score.

I assumed Zimmer skipped on creating a distinct theme for Blade Runner because he was only given a couple of months to put a score together and he didn't have time.

With Dune he'd have plenty of time and still no theme that cements in your memory. It's all soundscapes. Maybe he's past It or grown out of writing the things like Time for Inception.

reply

totally agree. it is full of clichees (arabian vocals above desert pictures) and still - he got a Golden Globe Nom. Totally absurd in my eyes!

reply

Yeah, the Arabian-esque was terrible. It's set on a planet far far away. Just because it's a desert doesn't mean it's Arab. That's just nonsense.

The same with the bagpipes music. Wth were they thinking?

reply

Yes and actually it got the Globe. Let's see if the Academy also thinks this was Oscar worthy...

reply