MovieChat Forums > Doctor Who (2006) Discussion > The companion is NOT Trans

The companion is NOT Trans


Yasmin Finney is an androgynous non-binary AMAB. From a search in google, they didn't even go on HRT, maybe some micro-dose to enforce the androgynous look. Yasmin is what's called a femboy, casted so young since twinkdeath will be there for them in 3-4 more years.

That's NO trans.

Trans people are people with gender dysphoria who medically transition to blend into the opposite sex. This is just a GNC femboy.

reply

Xou sound like an idiot.

reply

Xou sound like an idiot.

Offended? I'm so sorry I hurt your feelings 😂

reply

Not my feelings, so much as my language.

reply

In plain English what does any of that mean?
JB

reply

Some fantasy shit.

reply

Not every trans gpersons will undergo gender confirmation surgurynbut many will take suppliments to get the bodyshape they want dim suppliments do not require a doctors note and will help you grow breasts and a more feminine body,




Trans people do ot need to pass as the gender they know they are, to be trans, only the individual decides,




.

reply

"Trans people do ot need to pass as the gender they know they are, to be trans, only the individual decides,"

Moronic. So moronic.

reply

Thst is trans ideology. You are calling moronic just understand that.

You can b ae tansman who gets preganant

Yhe trans gender part is in the mind, not thebody




reply

Did you take gender studies 101? Why not say biological male instead of AMAB? GNC is a supplement. Yasmin is birth control!

reply

Why even say "biological male"???? Is there a non-biological male or ANY other form of male?

reply

Some charging cords are considered to have male and female types. If the Doctor regenerated into an Android phone, then the companion would be a charging cord.

reply

A trans person is neither a biological male nor a biological female. Biologically, he/she has elements from both sexes, you can't categorize that combination under one specific sex.

You could use "natal male" if you wish, "biological male" is not correct.

reply

Nope, you are talking about inter-sex.

Biologically a trans is (generally speaking) either male of female and suffers of gender dysphoria so will try to identify as much as possible as the opposite sex.

There is NO natal male or biological male. Just male.

Intersex usually are different than trans.

reply

Intersex have a mix of sexual characteristics by default.

Through medical treatment, an endosex person (not intersex) can reach a mix of sex characteristics. The same way, through medical treatment, an intersex person can have sex characteristics corresponding to one specific sex, instead of some middle point.

Some biological elements can not change.

Some others can.

reply

Confused? Double thinking? So characteristic of your kind.

You said:
"A trans person is neither a biological male nor a biological female. Biologically, he/she has elements from both sexes, you can't categorize that combination under one specific sex." - no that's NOT what trans is, that is what intersex is.

"Through medical treatment, an endosex person (not intersex) can reach a mix of sex characteristics."

Endosex has clear male or female characteristics, and contradicts your first statement. Through medical treatment the biological characteristics are NOT changed. Only certain characteristics can change, chemically, but still those are against the biology, they are pretty much artificial.

reply

Confused? Double thinking?

Just thinking. It's a healthy habit. You should try.

no that's NOT what trans is, that is what intersex is

Again: an intersex person has sex characteristics from the sex opposed to his/her chromosomal sex without medical intervention.

Endosex has clear male or female characteristics, and contradicts your first statement.

Again: endosex have clear male or female sex characteristics without medical intervention. A medical treatment can change that.

Through medical treatment the biological characteristics are NOT changed. Only certain characteristics can change, chemically, but still those are against the biology

Sex characteristics that changed because of HRT can't be against biology for one simple reason: biology is not an ideology.

reply

Are you dumb? Medical intervention is THE OPPOSITE of biological. As I was saying: doublethinking or just confused.



"biology is not an ideology." - exactly, so leave your ideology OUT of biology.

Cutting someone's dick IS NOT changing their biology you idiot. Changing someone's hormonal cycle through chemical processes (HRT) is again not biology. As soon as you stop chemically altering the body biology kicks in and changes the hormone production back to what biology is.

reply

You're talking about hermaphrodites ,not trans.

reply

Yasmin is a gorgeous woman.

reply

... but the show is NOT watchable, anyway.

reply