This is the best one out of the prequel trilogy

Revenge of the sith is the worst of the prequels
it has the worst dialogue and acting from the prequels.
the plot is completely predictable, there was NO TRANSFORMATION, all of a sudden he is completely evil and kills 5 years old kids without hesitation, huh?.
dying at child-birth must be COMPLETELY curable in the star wars galaxy, particularly Coruscant.
all of a sudden Obi wan has 110% chance of defeating Anakin just for being 4 meters above of him?

just because Vader is on it for 2 minutes your nostalgia makes you think it is as good as the Original trilogy



The stupid have one thing in common.They alter the facts to fit their views not the other way

Ur nitpicking my brother. EIII was great. You forgot about credit fonts at the end of the movie that weren't as blue as the originals.

Which is kind of like saying getting raped from the back is better from the front

I used to think Episode III was a very strong prequel movie, and it mostly is, but Anakin's transformation is really stupid.

Calls the Jedi evil, yet proceeds to slaughter children less than 30 minutes after giving Obi-Wan his best wishes.

Sees the evil of the Dark Side first hand with Sidious having ordered the invasion of Naboo ten years earlier, and the Attack of the Droids on Geonosis, not to mention everything in the clone wars, yet still joins it.

The same evil that nearly kills his precious Padme over and over again, yet joins the one who ordered her killed. It's just stupid.

Doesn't seem to realize that Palpatine was playing both sides and orchestrated the entire Republic vs. Droid Clone War. Again, stupid.

20 years between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope, what does Darth Vader do? Instead of realizing he is an idiot for slicing off Mace Windu's hands and then joining Palpatine, he continues to do Palpatine's bidding. Why?

Why?

I go with The Phantom Menace. I admit that TPM has some major flaws, too childish in parts, making Anakin a little kid, and of course JAR JAR! But the use of CGI was done better in that movie. They went practical in parts and also the sense of adventure and fun was ever-apparent throughout the movie. ROTS was depressing, but not in a good way, like TESB. All that CGI and how all the Jedis got duped so easily by Palpatine, plus the one-off way Anakin turned to the Dark Side really took away from any believability.

Or, of the three piles of junk, this one is more neatly piled.

Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.

Agreed, but thats not saying much.

It's hard to pick any as "best," because they're all so bad, but I think part 3 is the worst of the bunch.