i watched both movies in a row. conan was slow and boring (with one of the biggest action scenes being arnold punching a camel! wtf?!). red sonja, on the other hand, was way more entertaining - more action, fun characters, and nice set pieces. not sure why conan is considered a classic and everyone seems to hate red sonja.
From what little I recall, Red Sonja is a light, fluffy, bubblegum movie. It feels like the 80s equivalent of a 1960s Italian Sword & Sandal movie. Conan is a much more serious movie. The characters in Conan are much more developed. The setting feels real, not a fake Hollywood stage. The music is incredibly better. And if you think the camel punch was the action highlight of Conan I have to wonder where you were for the opening massacre, the pit-fights, the wolf-witch, the tower, etc. etc. etc. I saw Red Sonja once and never wanted to watch it again. All I remember is some goofy-looking warriors in armor that looked like elephant masks made of rubber-plant leaves and Red Sonja's 1980s aerobics mullet hairdo. I have watched Conan dozens of times and it never gets boring.
i agree with you. i liked the score and cinematography in conan better. calling the camel punch scene the action highlight of the movie was a joke of course.
but yet, it can't compensate for its flaws for me, such as the bad pacing and dialog. both are very campy movies, but the problem for me is that conan seems to take itself serious nonetheless, while red sonja doesn't pretend to be more than just a goofy fun flick.
Conan The Barbarian is an impressive epic classic. If anything, Conan The Destroyer and Red Sonja would make a better comparison. I like both, but Barbarian is one of the best sword and sandal epics I have ever seen.