I like


the lead, Katja Herbers. She caught my attention in The Leftovers and Westworld and others here and there. But I can't bring myself to watch a network show.

reply

She is magnetic, and should be included in this site’s cast credits, but nooooo . . . I recorded the pilot out of curiosity, then saw she was in it, and I am going to be hanging around. I share your dislike of broadcast network shows. The commercial breaks, heralded by RISING MUSIC that kneecaps the action and tosses a boat anchor into the narrative, combined with the imperative of lowest-common-denominator writing are two factors that make Premium Cable so attractive; BUT, Evil seems to be a CBS Police Procedural cut from cloth similar to Elementary, a network cop show that ticked off the obligatory boxes (44 minutes editorial content CHECK!, good triumphs over evil CHECK!, an IQ of 80 can follow it CHECK!, mildly controversial premise [drug addiction or minions of Hell] CHECK!, extremely winning lead and co-stars CHECK!, narrative better than one would expect on the network of geriatrics CHECK!). The pilot of Evil checked all these boxes, wrapped everything up in 44 minutes, and was still engaging, as horrific as a broadcast network TV show can be (the prospect of 4 murdered beautiful little girls?!) and still managed to engage a guy who calls himself R_Kane. I will keep watching.

reply

I did DVR it on a whim. You think it's worth a watch?

reply

I definitely think so. Even though not much happens, it had my full attention. The subtleties and nuances of the characters makes for an interesting flow between them without coming off as a morality play.

~~/o/

reply

she's very likable :)

reply

Quite a coincidence: last week, I binged Season 2 of Westworld, mainly because of Katja. She made the show more ALIVE and human, which is saying something. Now, I tune in to a new show about which I’ve profound doubts, and there she is!

reply

same here when it comes to network shows. just can't bring myself to watch a show from week to week.

reply

I don't care about week-to-week. For me, it's just the fact that broadcast is beholden to forces that limit creative freedom -- and you're reminded of that fact in the content and at every commercial break. It's hard to go back to cookie-cutter predictability after watching the stuff they do on cable/streaming.

reply

Too many police, fire and medical procedurals.

reply

The pilot was smart and captivating by its sense of mystery.

My main concern once invested in the show is I hope the writers do not trap themselves early on when the current storyline resolves itself.

This is crucial because it's easy for series like this to become repetitive after all the interesting avenues are taken.

Margarita in a can? Is this part of the growing trend?

~~/o/

reply

With any episodic series, there is that risk. Whether it be paranormal, crime, medical, or whatever. When I see a new show I always wonder how many story ideas they already have in mind.

We've had wine in cardboard boxes for years. Margaritas in a can were inevitable.

reply

That makes a lot of sense. I can only think that the haunted house stories can last for so long before having to go back to the drawing board for fresh ideas.

No doubt on that last part; just look at bottled water, most of the time it not being better than what comes out of the kitchen sink.

~~/o/

reply

Well, let’s see: Supernatural is in its 15th season, Penny Dreadful ran for 3 seasons, Grimm lasted, what?, 7 seasons? I believe there’s enough evil in the world to keep this puffing along for some time. Remember, Kristen is tying up with Assessors for the Catholic Church, which has a backlog of “about 500,00 requests” for exorcisms and assessments of miracles.

reply

Sometimes, it seems like it takes a boogeyman or a deceitful adversary to unite people in common cause.

The irony to your last part, R_Kane, is that in real life the Roman Catholic Church itself has been telling people, who believe they are demon-afflicted, that their condition is strictly mental and nothing more.

The Church has officially been enforcing this rigid policy for a while now due to the fact that there is such high demand to have an exorcism happen when not actually the case. It is funny that the Holy See has to be selectively picky much to a lot of people's disappointment.

~~/o/

reply

That’s a shame, twin. I am Episcopalian, but I have a great respect for the Catholic Church, because it embraces Mystery, which I think is beautiful. Demons are real, and that’s all I am going to say.

reply

That's all you need to say.

Which is the very basis of faith; to see without eyes, to hear devoid of ears, touching what cannot be felt and knowing presence by acknowledging what must be sought out in lieu of direct evidence.

~~/o/

reply

Truthfully, all religions and their theologies are fascinating.

I was not raised religious although instilled with a love of God, brought up by a Southern Baptist father and a Presbyterian (USA) mother.

Despite some sour church-related memories during my formative years, I have really come into my faith as a young adult, learning all it takes is a good experience.

After being denied by multiple clerics, who objected over my parent's decision to each retain their denominational faiths post union (likey on doctrinal issues relating to the sacrament of baptism), their wedding was officiated by an Episcopalian priest, who agreed with the marriage.

Generally speaking, all education should be valued, including religious education. Ignorance of any history is problematic, especially since a lot of it is at risk of being forgotten and the accompanying lessons such knowledge brings with it.

~~/o/

reply

Yes, there is a lot of evil in the world; lots of material. But how they use it is another matter. Sleepy Hollow ran for 3 seasons, and I could see them cutting their own throats in the middle of season 2. As to Supernatural, I lost interest along about season 5. Not saying it was bad, only that it didn't entertain me enough to keep watching.

reply

Regarding "Supernatural," the characters kept coming back way too many times, turning what was once a dramatic storytelling device into a tool to move the plot along. Besides, didn't the main showrunner leave for other prospects by the fifth season?

~~/o/

reply

Oh so agree- she is superb! Hebers is what drew me in.
The rest of the cast is great, too.

reply

So far, the casting is uniformly impressive. I have high hopes for the no-bullshit nun, Sister Agnes.

reply