So for some they basically got TWO good films.


....and the rest were bad. So Star Wars as a whole SUCKS....πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

reply

I think only the Disney stuff truly sucks as it's not needed.

As for those who claim ROTJ sucks... well, they've got ridiculously high expectations.

reply

ROTJ is still my least favorite. I just rewatched it the other day and except for a couple scenes i still do not like it anymore than we I first saw it in 83..

I know ESB is most people favorite but I still feel ROTS is the best of the series. The end lightsaber battle is awesome...

reply

Let me clarify about ROTJ:

I LOVE LOVE LOVE The Battle of Endor, all three ways. I think it is THE single best space battle in the whole saga.

I don't care so much for Han's rescue from Jabba's Palace and all of that, as it recently occurred to me that this segment would not happen AT ALL if Lucas respected Ford's decision not to return.

And the bit I find most boring is when they first arrive on Endor and the Ewok stuff, up until Luke rescues them from being literally roasted (and 3PO's little part as well). After that, it all rocks.

So I can see why you don't like it. It was, however, the very first Star Wars I saw in the cinema with my big sister, so it has a special place in my heart.

reply

Return of the Jedi is a mixed bag for me. The ending has some of the greatest moments in the entire franchise, but you have to sit through a lot of boring kiddie nonsense to get there. Overall I like it because of the last act but the buildup definitely could have been better. The Jabba sequence was entertaining enough but overall unnecessary to the main plot.

reply

Six good movies. 3 pieces of shit via Disney

reply

Some really hated the prequels also though...

reply

They are misterunderstood masterpieces

reply

Well I enjoy them and Rots Is my all time favorite SW film, and I'm an old time fan...

reply

The only truly good film of the entire lot is the first one.

reply

8 good movies

OT x 3
ROTS
TFA
Rogue one
Solo
TROS

reply

The way I see it there are 4 good films (Empire Strikes Back, A New Hope, Revenge Of The Sith, Return Of The Jedi)
2 films that are neutral (Attack Of The Clones, Phantom Menance)
And the rest are trash (The Last Jedi, Solo, Rogue One, Rise Of Skywalker, The Force Awakens)

reply

I see it exactly the same, although I quit watching Star Wars before most, so haven’t watched Solo, Last Jedi or Rise Of Skywalker, only clips of them.

reply

- The Last Jedi: I feel the acting is better than TFA and Rogue One however there are so many insane decisions made in that film and the way they treated Luke Skywalker is absurd

- Solo: Pretty harmless for the most part until the very end where it just becomes ridiculous, but it's boring and really unnecessary, also what they did with Lando's character was just bizarre

- Rise Of Skywalker: Don't even waste your time, it is an incoherent mess with no direction. The entire film is basically just a scavenger hunt and it's not nearly as well executed as you might think. Also having the Emperor returns completely undermines what Luke and Anakin did in Episode VI. Very poor ending to a franchise.

reply