MovieChat Forums > The Irishman (2019) Discussion > Honestly, this movie was too short.

Honestly, this movie was too short.


This should have been a mini-series. I don't mean add filler just to fill an unnecessary quota like many Netflix shows do. I'd say about 7-9 half hour episodes would have done this story justice. Add about an hour of content to help connect more dots and develop more ideas and answer more questions, than divide it into episodes to let the story breath. There's too much material for a movie. You could feel it buckling under its own weight, often times zipping through plot points in one minute because there's thirty more that need attention. There's not enough time to let it absorb, and it became abundantly clear that Scorsese was relying on narration as a crutch for exposition. ]

There were so many complex relationships and motivations and back-stories that needed to be explained in order for the ensuing plot line and action to make sense to the audience, but because there wasn't enough time, he couldn't dedicate any more celluloide to make you feel it through visual story-telling, so he cheaply relied on the narrator to give you a quick bullet point break down of why this character is doing this. It lost a lot of its emotional impact as a result.


reply

7 half hour episodes would do the story justice? So 3 and a half hour runtime would be enough?... That's what it was.

reply

Some of the users here aren’t overly bright.

reply

Funny that you say that, because the extended version of the "Hateful 8" shows up on Netflix as a 3 episode mini-series.

But, The Irishman, though a big national event, is not really worthy of an extended treatment. I did some digging and it's most likely full of misinformation, not to mention how they pull in the JFK assassination into the story as if it is a given. It's like an Italian FU to America.

Scorsese can go jump in the lake as far as I am concerned.

reply

[deleted]

I did some digging and it's most likely full of misinformation

Can you give some link? I feel curious.

reply

[deleted]

Yes, I was thinking it could have worked well as a series.

reply