MovieChat Forums > Titanic (1997) Discussion > Do you think God destroyed Titanic becau...

Do you think God destroyed Titanic because of unmarried sex between Jack & Rose?


It was a sin they committed !

reply

You can't POSSIBLY think they were the only fornicating couple on board!

On a ship with that many people on board, no relatives or neighbors to spy on anyone, nothing else to do but eat and play shuffleboard...

reply

Yeah, Leontine Aubart is specifically referenced in the movie as Benjamin Guggenheim's mistress, but the two of them couldn't possibly have been having any unmarried sex on that ship. Why on earth would they have been doing that?

reply

LOL

reply

This explains everything.

But why did he let Rose survive?
Was it some kind of purgation?

reply

Ha ha.

What about all those gay cruise boats we have now, why hasn't he sunk those? He must have given up.

reply

I think with the real-life ship, it had more to do with God teaching the White Star Line (and other steamship companies at the time) what happens when you are so arrogant about a ship's build that you don't put people's safety first. It was also a lesson on prioritizing safety over class and gender. There were a lot of lessons God taught during the Industrial Revolution when it came to the human factor. Titanic was just [excuse the pun] the tip of the iceberg.

reply

Yeah, the REAL sin was not putting enough lifeboats on board for everybody.

reply

Oh there were MANY more sins than that. Like not planning ahead with the ship's engineering, such as building bulkheads that didn't go up to the boat deck. Or not having ships keep their radios on no matter what.

Are you aware that there was a ship just a few miles away called the Californian, who could have saved Titanic, but the head radio operator got mad that night and shut the radio off because people kept bothering him? Then, when they saw the flares going up from Titanic, they did nothing. They thought it was some unusual light phenomena in the night. Titanic's captain also ignored ice warnings and let two corporate CEO's dictate to him how fast to drive the ship, even though navigating the north Atlantic was dangerous in early April. There was also the issue of lack of communication within the ship's staff, technology involving spotting icebergs and operating the lifeboats being too slow, and other problems. There was also the competition factor.

Titanic was an example of letting corporate competition show just how far people would go to ignore the human factor when it came to safety.

reply

Lots of "sins", lots of carelessness, lots of bad decisions, but really - I think the single worst thing anyone did was to dismiss the need for lifeboats. Everything else was ordinary everyday carelessness and stupidity, but a failure to place lifeboats was flat-out criminal negligence if not mass murder.

People complain about rules and regulations, but the fact is that almost every annoying rule or regulation happened because somebody fucked up and harm was done.

reply

Sad, but true.

reply

Norm Macdonald: "Hey I've been doing some research, turns out the Titanic was sunk by a Jew. Yeah some guy named Iceberg."

:(

reply

[deleted]