MovieChat Forums > The Princess Bride (1987) Discussion > How does Buttercup become a princess?

How does Buttercup become a princess?


In the beginning of the movie, Buttercup is a peasant like Westley is. Five years later, she is the princess of Florin without explanation. What does the book say about that?

reply

Don't know about the book, but the movie explains it: The King announces to his people that he want to marry a commoner like them, and make her royal... that is it. He just chooses a chick from his fold. We can assume he does this to connect his kingdom better together or something... when he announces this he also announces it is in connection with the 500 year anniversary of his country... so I suppose it has something to do with unity or other... anyway, the movie explains that the king want to marry a commoner and so she becomes a princess-to-be.

reply

HAL 9010, your ending is my point. After the opening Buttercup is engaged to Humperdinck, who is the prince, not king, but the wedding never takes place. Still, everyone bows to Buttercup and calls her 'Your Highness'. The young woman is referred to as 'Princess Buttercup' upon her introduction to Florin, but needs to marry the prince before holding that title.

reply

Yes, my bad. He was a prince.

Since the title is: Princess Bride... well, isn’t she? I mean a “bride” is by definition not yet... so technically she is not a Princess she is a “Princess Bride”... aka a Princess to be. Splitting hairs perhaps, but it could redeem your valid point. No ?

As a comparison, those who for example engage British Royalty are treated royally even before becoming officially tilted.... weak, I know. :)

reply

In that case, Florin is a kingdom that will for some odd reason honor future titles of the fiancées of royalty. Buttercup never becomes a princess after all. Thank you, HAL 9010. I'm glad that you recognize the bottom line of my question which is so readily accepted that many members of the audience don't think about it.

reply

It can also be seen as that was her relative title.

She's a farm girl from nowhere thrust into the spotlight because she's the bride of the prince - or soon to be - so what will she be referred to when people gossip (because you can't refer her by her name, they probably don't know it) - the princess bride. Or maybe it's a cheeky reference to classic fairytale's where the woman is always some imperilled princess and/or destined to be a bride.

reply

Prince Humperdinck is so arrogant and self-centered that he wants to immediately bring his chosen bride to his social level. That supports his decision in the first place which is based on the agreement that Buttercup is the most beautiful young lady in the kingdom. That is smart, Mavican, and probably right. Thank you.

reply

I like your answer better! Haha. I also think maybe the author, who is obviously taking the piss of all the cliched characters, just made her a princess because in fairytales it's always a princess.

reply

Thank you, but I thought that it was what you meant too when you said 'relative title'. I was paraphrasing your idea and calling it smart. Did I accidentally get the answer from you?

reply

Eh, i think were trying to apply to much logic to this movie, let's just say it's somewhere between the two haha.

reply

Okay. You're also talking about how the story is to some degree a parody of fairy tales despite it being one. That allows a peasant suddenly being promoted to princess to speak for itself.

reply

She clearly had some kind of higher status than Westley in the beginning, as she ordered him around and haughtily called him "farm boy."

reply

Buttercup does not have a greater social class than Westley, but he is employed by her family. She is infatuated with him and suspects that he shares her feelings, so she pushes her limits with him.

reply

Good point.

reply

Thank you, LivingMCM.

reply

Farm boy? I thought she called him homeboy.


[spoiler]Just kidding[/spoiler]

reply

I read somewhere that in the book, Humperdink simply made up that she was related to royalty of some obscure or made up country.

reply

Thank you, crood. That lie would be convenient enough for Prince Humperdinck.

reply

Basically, Prince Humperdink chose Buttercup because she was the most beautiful woman in the kingdom, and gave her the title and privileges of princess. He had her move into his castle, put on the princess duds, engaged himself to her, and presented her new royal status to the world.

This has actually happened in real life, believe it or not. Not everyone gained (in past or present) a royal title by birth. Sometimes it was granted to them as a gift from a ruling monarch, or gained through marriage. However, people in the court always made it clear where the new guy/girl stood compared to the rest of them, particularly if they were a foreigner.

reply

Thank you, AmeriGirl26. As written, I have assumed something along that line.

reply

Very late to the party: Humperdinck chooses a commoner because he wants to have her killed, to have the killing blamed on Guilder, a neighboring kingdom, and therefore have an excuse to start a war with them. Remember he mentions to Rugen that he hired Vizzini to kill her, and mused that strangling her on their wedding night will be even more effective in rousing the people against Guilder. Killing a commoner will be ever so much less politically complicated than doing the same to a bride from a powerful family either in Florin or outside it. Her beauty and his arrogance regarding that aspect is incidental to his main (and arrogant) plan to go to war.

reply

Thank you, ejbronte. It's never too late to respond to my posts. I know everything that you have written, but do you think that Prince Humperdinck lies about Buttercup's status just to make his plan more convenient?

reply

I never really thought about it, but it now makes sense. I mean, she was technically living alone as an adult when the prince picked her up, and she was not only a peasant, but one of the prince's subjects. Plus, the girl was also serving as a temporary trophy wife. I mean, Humperdink was a vain man, and wanted only a beautiful bride to be with him at the altar, even if she wasn't of royal blood.

reply