How Far Right is this?


Four people on the poster and they are ALL Caucasian? It's 2022!!!

Is this even worth watching or is it just propaganda?

reply

Whites are 70% of the adult population. It's a movie happening in 1939 when America was about 90% White. It's a movie made for Western audience. There is no logical reason that TIME should be a factor for how many minorities are in the movie, unless you're a bigot who just doesn't want to see White people.

reply

I think he's just a stupid troll trying to piss people off; it's obvious that a movie in the 30's about carnival would have only whites because that's how society was; just like now a movie about LA or Chicago gangs would have only blacks and latinos because this is factual situation.

Anyway great movie 8/10.

reply

Time matters because audiences change and this isn't 1939 anymore. Look at shows like Bridgerton and how seamlessly BAME actors have integrated into the story.

Representation matters.

reply

Whites are still 70% of the adult population. In Britain, Whites are 87% of the population and even more of the adult population. Having many minorities in a movie happening in 1939 just because they are today a larger percentage doesn't make any more sense than having Blacks and Whites in a movie about ancient China.

reply

You're a sucker for responding

reply

How so? This guy wasn't trolling. He was being serious.

reply

The thread below this one (and many other threads on movies) all ask the same stupid question:

"How WOKE is this movie" i.e. How LEFT is this movie.

OP made a thread called: How FAR RIGHT is this movie.

Yes, he was trolling you.

EDIT* His username is Guy Haynes. The other thread is by GuyHaines.

reply

This^

reply

This is the post I was replying to:

Time matters because audiences change and this isn't 1939 anymore. Look at shows like Bridgerton and how seamlessly BAME actors have integrated into the story.

Representation matters.


I see nothing trolling here. A serious arugment.

reply

There is nothing serious about that, I assure you.

reply

Racist trolls: criticize movies for being woke is they cast minorities, mock movies that don't have minorities.

reply