The Chinese joke


While I accept there was no malice and offense intended, you really cannot evalute how a native Chinese person in China would react.

The Chinese have every right to be offended. What Westerners fail to understand about China and Chinese people is that they suffered a century of humiliation, the Forbidden Palace was looted, conceded Hong Kong, forced to take Opium... this was all when China was weak. Now that China is experiencing a revival, both economically and financially. They can and will be more assertive, geopolitically, etc.

So the Asian dude said what kind of knees are these? Chin-knees. Haha... ok... I thought the joke not offensive but stupid, but a Chinese person in China would think WTF? Chinese, knees? Dirty knees from kneeling? One hundred years of humuliation. WTF??

I understand it is not an American production, correct me if I am wrong, it's a joint, Chinese, German and Japanese production. The Chinese production company Tencent really dropped the ball here. They should have been assertive and spoken up about this since they know their home market. If I were one of the financiers of this film, I would be mad as F. There's a lot on the line here (millions), and they really are going to make a racially crude joke that *could* be taken in a bad way. NOTE to filmmakers, don't make any risky racial connotation jokes.

They deserve to lose the China market for being so stupid.

reply

How many posts do you want to make on this?

Oh I can bet why you're offended...

reply

A million posts, dude.

reply

I've seen 2 so far , neither actually exaplioning what was said , just assuning i knew.
i dont know.
what was the joke?

reply

It was an inoffensive. It was banter between a Whitie and Asian actor. It was improvised on set by the Asian actor. It was a silly, inoffensive joke.

The Asian actor said to the whitie actor, "What knees are these? THey are Chin-knees". -- THat's it, really. Nothing.

I get the joke, but I just think it is silly and stupid and throw-away. I don't think it is "funny" and I accept there was no malice in it.

If I get the joke and I find it stupid and disposable. The Chinese public in China clearly didn't get the joke, and have taken offense to it. Chinese knees, CHinese kneeing, dirty knees, one hundred years of humiliation at the hands of Westerners. The looting of the Forbidden Palace, Opium War, conceding of Hong Kong islands.

reply

ah , i see , thanks

reply

What a bunch of whiney bullcrap

reply

Intestingly, the movie was pulled from theaters. That means it was cleared by the censor bureau. So the goverment / Communist Party actually didn't mind. It was the uproar from netizens that make them change their minds and finally ban the movie.

reply

What scene in the movie is or was the joke?
Was it between Tony Jaa and Milla as he couldn't understand or talk English so im a bit confused as the where this so called was.

reply

It's been cut in all versions.

reply