MovieChat Forums > Dumbo (2019) Discussion > Do you think people are catching on that...

Do you think people are catching on that Disney is creatively bankrupt.


Marvel Studio and Pixar might have some original ideas left. But Disney Studios itself is so devoid of originality that all they do now is Remake movies from 70 years ago. And it seems like now it might be affecting the box office. Im not sure if people will show up to see Will Smith play a Smurf either.

reply

Can't say I blame them really. All the stories have been told already. Every "new" one is just a retelling. The same for Marvel and Pixar. The difference with Disney's live-action adaptations is they are being upfront about it.

Though I have to admit this one was a lot different than the original.

reply

People may be catching on. Dumbo has made substantially less money than Mary Poppins Returns. I assume they are biting their nails a bit about Aladdin and The Lion King remakes but...in today's international markets, movies don't really bomb anymore, they just underperform.

I think what's sad is that these sequels and remakes are pretty assembly-line jobs, action movies instead of heart-warming tales like Disney used to make.

reply

I would agree that most remakes are kinda assembly-line patchups. But with Dumbo there seemed to be an added problem of having nothing creative to add. Most of the original Dumbo took place in about 40 minutes of this and then the rest felt like Tim Burton trying to be creative and failing.

I don't think there's any getting around the routine aspect of movies nowadays. Even Inside Out felt like it was cooked up on an assembly line. But it still worked. When Disney goes original is when they seem to fail. The second half of Dumbo, a Wrinkle in Time, the Last Jedi, Tomorrowland. And when they do it they get criticized heavily for not giving audiences what they want.

I should correct myself that not all stories have been told already. But my point stands that all the good ones have.

reply

Replace Disney with Hollywood and yeah. Last year was the worst fiscal year for them this millenium, and i'm sure this year is gonna end up no better. Awards shows like Oscars and Golden Globe have had record lows the last few years.

reply

The worst part is, they're totally clueless to the fact that the public has caught on to it.

reply