MovieChat Forums > Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle (2017) Discussion > The twist that never was *spoilers*

The twist that never was *spoilers*


Did anyone else feel like there was a twist that never came in this film?

Alex had been in Jumanji for many, many years and somehow managed to not lose his 3rd life, despite having to survive alone. Contrast this to the other heroes who all lose most of their lives within a very short time during the film.

Alex claims to have lost 2 of his 3 lives trying to do the transport section. This level appears to come after the Snake challenge which is only survived by the team of heroes because they work together. Alex references this challenge later in the film suggesting he also had to attempt it, but it's not explained how he survived it.

When the team are escaping through the tunnels under the city, they nearly set off several impossible to see traps. Alex helps them through this, knowing each trap perfectly. How could he have ever worked out all these traps without losing a single life?

Just after this scene, the gang have to cross a pit of crocodiles. Alex remarks that getting eaten by then "is a horrible way to die" - but he cant have been eaten by them himself, as we already know how he lost his 2 lives.

Eventually we see Alex die from a single mosquito bite. Are we to believe that he has never been bitten in all the years of being there? The film shows he has candles to keep them away at night, but surely he would have been bitten well before finding Alan's camp and the candles.

My theory is that Alex had actually died 1000's of times. He worked out all the traps and challenges by trail and error, a classic video game mechanic that would have suited the films style well.

My guess is that they were working in a twist where Alex was using a cheat code (another classic videogame trope) to get "unlimited lives" but eventually, due to time or complication, they decided to change the story at the last minute, meaning some clues were left in the final cut.

What do you think?




reply

I wondered how he survived for so long when the others lost their lives within such a short time. IMO, it's just something that was overlooked by the writers. One of those things you can't take too seriously if you wanna enjoy the movie.

reply

Finding out Alex’s identity was the twist to me. It IS the movie’s twist. When we learn he is the kid who’s been missing for 20 years, I didn’t expect any more surprises from his character. I hear what you’re saying, but I personally did not get the impression he was hiding something more from simply looking at how visibly shocked he was to realize how long he had been in the game.

The eaten by crocodiles line does sound curious. But then again, you don’t have to be eaten by crocodiles to know it would be a painful way to go. Lol
Here’s a theory to fill in the potential holes: MAYBE after one would lose their three lives in the game, the game restarts itself and then the player would have to start from the beginning... only they would have no recollection they had played before — exactly like a real video game. Just a thought.

reply

unless you remember Metallica shirt.

reply

Darn!

Well, that’s easy to miss the first time.

reply

Time passed at different times. In real life he was there for years. In the game he said he was only there a few months. After losing the first two lives he decided to lay low.

reply

[deleted]

That would have been a good twist. Maybe he decided to flee the game and went by sea far far away and found an unlimited life bonus. But still, couldn't complete the game without the others.

reply

I expected him to turn out to be an antagonist who first gains their trust and then later somehow screws them up for his own benefit, i.e. to get out of the game.

But the movie decided to have a more boring plot for him.

reply

I kinda wondered what would happen if they did lose a life. I felt like this was definitely intentionally less scary than the original. Who's to say that if they did lose all their lives they would actually die irl, they go back in time once it's over so maybe he would come back to life if they won.

reply