MovieChat Forums > Black Panther (2018) Discussion > What do you guys think about the popular...

What do you guys think about the popular category the Oscars are instituing? (A possible nod to this film)


Its no surprise or news by now that the Oscars are an extremely biased event in order to help hollywood and for upshowing their political views. I really wonder if this movie is going to win for being politicaly correct. But on my opinion that Oscar shoud go to Infinity War.

reply

I'm hoping it turn out to be some kind of elaborate joke. Just because a movie makes a lot in the Box Office doesn't necessarily make it worthy of an award.

reply

It's an extremely silly category, and I'd like to know the official qualifications for entry. Is it limited to films that made over 500 mil at the box office, or greater than ten times their budget?

But I see it as pandering to the fans of comic book films and other popular genres, not as another attempt to increase diversity in awards. Because face it, most of the big-money popular films made today star white people.

reply

Totally agreed. I myself am against even the animated movie category.. since there are so many stinkers running up for it. And I could be wrong, but I don't remember if ever an artistic animated film winning the oscar over a commercial one

reply

Oh, I'm all for awarding the Animated category, even if the category was created to keep animated films out of the Best Picture awards.

But "Best Popular Film" sounds like a desperate attempt to stay relevant, one created by people who were last relevant in 1962.

reply

John Campea from youtube said he thinks popular film category is lowering these popular films. Kinda like. Ok guys, you can't make it to best picture, so we are gonna create a category just for you!

reply

Yeah, I think they're trying to do what they did with the Animated category, keep the whole genre out of the Best Picture category while hopefully not alienating fans of the pictures they don't want to praise too highly.

Honestly, I think this is an attempt to deal with the incredible ongoing success of Marvel Films.

reply

The big problem is divided movies into comedy and drama. This isn't medieval England or ancient Greece!

At the minimum we need a category for sci-fi and adventure.

reply

I dont know man... the category in which a movie fits is extremely subjective. We see so many films that a bunch of people consider to be something and a bunch the contrary.. sometimes the movie fits into like 4 genres.

reply

"On Wednesday, the Academy announced in a statement that it is dropping the widely criticized "popular film" category it introduced less than a month ago from the 2019 awards, saying it has determined the award "merits further study."NPR


Yes they look desperate. But their ratings are in decline and they want to please everybody and not take any more criticism.

reply

Good

reply

Well that didn't pan out.

reply