MovieChat Forums > X (2022) Discussion > The "landslide" scene.

The "landslide" scene.


Almost everyone in my theater laughed at the "landslide" scene.
Being an immigrant I might not understand the context.
Could someone please explain?

Thank you

reply

they laughed? i can't imagine why. i didn't find it funny at all.

maybe there was some kind of inside joke that went over my head too - & i'm not an immigrant.

i thought it was meant sincerely & i thought it was a great little performance. if it was meant to be funny the joke's lost on me.

i loved this movie.

reply

thinking about it a little bit, i guess some people may have laughed at it because they saw it as skewering sincere-seventies folkie sentimentality. maybe the film-makers meant it that way, but that's certainly not how it played to me.

nobody in the theatre laughed here. that said, there were only 5 or 6 people there (i saw it at a matinee showing yesterday, & those are always sparsely attended here).

reply

I watched at a 90% packed Thursday night showing in Burbank, CA.
Most of them probably Horror movie fans.
I wish I would understand why they laughed.

reply

i think i might have an answer!

that actress (named brittany snow, apparently) was in the pitch perfect movies. i don't know those movies, have never seen them, but i know enough about them to be aware that they're full of singing.

so i'm guessing that scene was meant as a little self-aware joke at her role in that franchise.

it still didn't play as 'funny' to me. if that was her singing, she did a great job imo. she has a very nice voice.

reply

Actually they started laughing when the dude started playing the guitar, before she started singing, so I doubt it was the reason.
Dang, that one's gonna haunt me...

reply

fwiw, i asked two people i follow on twitter who are very much into horror movies if they found the performance funny and if anyone in their theatre laughed. here are their responses:

"No I thought it was a nice scene actually she has a good singing voice and I’m a Stevie Nicks fan anyway. I didn’t get the impression it was meant to be humorous."

"well that's weird. no one laughed. i thought it was really nice and the singing was beautiful."

not to sound too ocd-ish, but i'm now kinda obsessed with trying to work out why anyone would find that scene funny!

reply

If it had been a different movie, it would've worked well, but for being a horror film it just took me completely out of it. All of the "emotional" scenes just ruined the tension and took me out of the movie.

reply

I hate to say it like this but people laugh for different reasons. Unless someone working on the script came forward to explain why anything about that scene is funny there is no answer. It's like asking for the meaning of life, different people will give a different answer.

Don't stew over it too much 😊

reply

It ruins the mood of the movie. My group and I laughed because someone picking up a guitar to do a singalong is just so out of place. This happened in The Conjuring too and it is comical.

As the song went on, I became more disturbed because of the theme being dealt with in the movie. BUT for the first 20 seconds, yeah it was funny.

reply

The one in Conjuring was actually really dumb and laughable, the one in X I thought was very soothing and touching, and like somebody else said it was like a calm before the violence.

reply

I didn't find that scene funny at all and I don't think it was intended to be humorous. I thought it was a great scene and a really nice moment of calm before the violence started.

reply

exactly.

reply

THERE IS NOTHING FUNNY ABOUT THIS AND I WILL DIE ON THIS HILL.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuKE0p2Zvu8&ab_channel=USED2KN0WME

reply

It certainly wasn't intended to be funny. I didn't find anything funny about it at all. It felt really in-place with the mood that was happening at the moment. If anything, it felt rather depressing due to the scenes that were playing simultaneously.

reply

not completely relevant but the first thing that song makes me think of is when south park used it in an episode.

reply