Who’d make a better Mr. Roark?

For this incarnation? hell, you could have put Ron Pearlman as the guy.. would have made no difference, as it was just a jaunt, and didn't catch my imagination.

Benjamin Bratt. If you've seen him on "Modern Family", you know he does Ricardo Montalban's accent and style better than anybody, and can be funny.

Benicio Del Toro

Which ever one of the three can best exude an undercurrent of menace. Michael Peña is a decent enough actor, but he doesn't have the weight to play Mr. Roarke.

Why don't we shake things up and have Peter Dinklage be the guy who runs the island, and his assistant who runs around yelling about planes could be played by Brad Pitt

I'd love to see Aubrey Plaza play Mr/Ms. Roarke.