MovieChat Forums > Black Swan (2010) Discussion > Was Nina being sexually abused by her mo...

Was Nina being sexually abused by her mother?


This article https://faithallen.wordpress.com/2011/01/03/black-swan-movie-about-mother-daughter-sexual-abuse/ suggests the theme of mother-daughter sexual abuse in the film was "glaringly obvious".

"Anyone can tell that there is something “off” in Nina’s relationship with her mother (played by Barbara Hershey). Nina is supposed to be in her 20’s, but she acts like a little girl in her mother’s presence, using words like “mommy” and “yummy.” Nina’s bedroom looks like a little girl’s room with lots of stuffed animals. Nina’s mother undresses her and treats her like a little girl. Her mother also chastises Nina for scratching herself (similar to cutting)."

What is your interpretation?

reply

I had that feeling. When I bring it up it makes people uncomfortable of course, but I think there were many elements of this. I also saw that article you shared and thought it was accurate.

reply

Incest is sexy in Hollywood! Just look at U-Turn or Nip / Tuck!!!

reply

I never felt she was being sexually abused. But I do think her mom damaged her emotionally by being overprotective and controlling.

reply

I agree with ilahilda. I don't think Nina was sexually abused by her mother.

reply

No. She was not.

reply

No but her Mother is abusive to her though, it was not shown in the film but it was hinted in the way Nina behaves with her Mom. There is a passive aggressive vibe in certain scenes (the ''cake'' scene most notably) where the Mother is showing her hostility towards her daughter. It actually bleeds over in the scene where as in others it's bottled up.

I get the impression there was a fair bit of physical abuse when Nina was younger. Even physical abuse as an adult. Her Mother was also ''arresting'' her emotional and sexual development. She tried to keep her at the emotional age of about 12. Also some jealousy, my guess is that Nina was about 23 and the Mother in her early 50's and was jealous of her daughters career and youth. A career the Mother once had but never the talent or the success to her Daughters level.

reply

I don't think so. I just think her mom was over-controlling about Nina's appearance, in a sort of narcissistic way. She wanted Nina to be physically perfect, because physical perfection and beauty is what was required for her dancing career and to take on the role of becoming the black swan. I didn't get the hint of any sexual abuse at all. In fact, on the contrary, I think Nina's mother wanted to shield her from all sexual thoughts / behavior, because she wanted her to strictly focus on her goals in dancing. But in the end, her mother's over-controlling tactics failed, because Nina couldn't deny her primal urges.

reply

I always come away from this movie feeling as though Nina's mom had an unhealthy obsession with her, and that she was living vicariously through Nina. The mom was very manipulative, (celebration cake) controlling, and overbearing, but I never got the sense that Nina was being sexually abused.

reply

That's how saw it to. As an unhealthy relationship that infantilized Nina but no sexual abuse.

reply

She wanted her daughter to be a machine for ballet. Human urges like sexual desire would have made Nina less ''focused'' in the eyes of her Mother. Notice how Nina was unable to stand up to anyone? not just her Mom but the other girls in her ballet company that were giving her a hard time (kind of the adult version of bullying).

She wasn't just sexually repressed but emotionally repressed. Maybe she would have quit if it wan't for this weird mental state her Mother put her in - like the poster says in this thread her Mother wanted to live through her vicariously. Maybe a ballet career wasn't what Nina really wanted at all. Most of the movie was Nina breaking out of her shell, starting to talk back to other people and advocating for herself (asking for the part). Her sexuality awakened and she defied the mother. Most of the breakdown and her (spoiler) death could be interpreted as a rebirth.

reply

I remember wondering if her mom even existed or of she was a figment of Nina's imagination.

reply