MovieChat Forums > Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (1999) Discussion > Why would the fake queen send the real q...

Why would the fake queen send the real queen to go clean a droid?


What would be the purpose of this and why would the queen agree to do it? They were on the ship and could just wait until the Jedi’s left. They didn’t have to use the decoy

reply

Why would a queen's handmaiden clean a droid at all? She sent a lady in waiting to perform the work of a technician.

But, yes, very little about the Star Wars prequels makes logical sense.

reply

Technician? From what I could see, only the OUTSIDE of the droid was being cleaned, so a lady-in-waiting would be perfectly suitable.

reply

When Luke is cleaning R2-D2 in the first Star War, he's fiddling around in the bits between panels and is using tools and things. I just assumed that a thorough cleaning of a droid would involve some maintenance beyond the external. But, perhaps Amidala was only meant to polish up the droid.

Still, the OP's point stands: the queen should not be sent to polish up a droid.

Also, while a servant would be suited to cleaning and polishing the mechanized silverware, I think (if my viewing of BBC period dramas serve me well) a queen's lady-in-waiting would probably be above that work. Of course, who knows where "droid polisher" would sit on the servant scale.

reply

Hahahaha, OMFG, and we're talking about ALIENS here. They can't POSSIBLY be the same as us!

reply

Aliens that behave in very similar ways to us.

They have a senate and other forms of government we recognize. They have clothing. They have problems with trade, taxes, and economics. They have hierarchies.

Look, it's all speculation, but that's the fun of talking about these alternate worlds, isn't it?

reply

Aliens that elect monarchs? Naaah, we never did that, correct me if I'm wrong. Even when I heard those relevant lines on Attack of the Clones (I served two terms) I thought it sounded stupid.

Then again, this reminds me of the Centauri Republic in Babylon 5: they are a republic, yet they have an Emperor. Nuts, eh?

reply

I'm not saying it's one-to-one, although I will certainly agree that very little thought seems to have been put into it.

As nuts as England? They're a constitutional monarchy, so they have voting rights and an Empress. Or maybe as nutty as the Roman Empire with its Senate and Caesar combo.

reply

While I hate to use those hypocrite frauds at RLM as a positive frame of reference for anything these days, I was amused by their take on this back in the day with their Pinkett review as it potentially being a game Padme played with her Handmaiden/decoy. e.g. "When I'm the queen I'm gonna have you clean toilets. Tee-hee!"

reply

RLM are awesome, hilarious, and made some expert videos about the prequels.

reply

LOL!

reply

Laugh if you like; I think those videos are insightful and well-made. They make a lot of great points about writing and crafting a story (the character depth test, for instance).

How could you not like the gag where they suggest Darth Maul was Star Wars' first homosexual?

reply

And the little Jabba guy being the first jew. Those reviews have a crazy joke/minute ratio

reply

Plinkett reviews (along with RLM as they made them famous) and Lego Star Wars are the only positives that came from the prequels.

reply

Yeah, I'd agree with that.

reply

You can dislike the prequels or love the abomination that was the Di$ney trilogy as much as you like but at the end of the day the prequels greatly expanded the lore & created characters that are beloved to this day. Di$ney trilogy will be forgotten in less than 10 years with a good chance of being retconned because that's how little fans give a sh*t about them.

reply

Ugh. Prequel lore isn't lore worth having.

reply

Why do you have to like the sequels to dislike the prequels who are on all accounts terrible movies?

reply

Am I talking with a two headed sock monster here?

" prequels who are on all accounts terrible movies?"

LOL! Okay

reply

Personally I like the Original Trilogy way better than the prequels or sequel trilogy.

reply

[deleted]

to give her a break.

reply

A working break? She should've just said, "Hey, Padme, take a long lunch!"

reply

The purpose behind this was so the real Queen could move around without anyone noticing her, and she could gather information on what was going on on her own ship, things they wouldn't actually tell her if she was still running around in royal regalia. It was part of a security setup Padmé, her handmaidens, and Captain Panaka all came up with back when she first was elected.

The entire situation was dangerous, because first off, her best-trained handmaiden could get killed at any time, with assassins mistaking her for the real Queen, or Padmé herself could get killed running around as a handmaiden, though most who didn't know about the decoy trick would not see her as an important target in an assassination. Granted, Padmé and all her handmaidens had been trained in combat, and all of her handmaidens had been trained to put their lives on the line and pretend to be her, but there was always the risk they could get killed, despite living on a peaceful planet.

Although, now that you mention it, the Queen's handmaiden kinda ranks very high in the servant hierarchy, and while it would seem odd to have such a high-ranking servant doing something so menial, things were crazy when they escaped the planet, and the people in the cargo bay and lower decks were more than happy for an extra set of hands to help out. Plus, the "Queen" had "ordered" her to clean the droid, and when you work for her, you don't say no, no matter how weird the assignment.

reply

This is one of the most important conversations happening on the Internet today.

reply