Remake time!!!!


🤷‍♂️

reply

Didn't the BBC do a recent miniseries?

reply

Better on the big screen.

And hopefully kept out of Alfonso Cabron’s hands so he doesn’t butcher it like “Great Expectations”.


reply

I don't know. I prefer the BBC miniseries better than any of the movies based on Austin's work.

reply

Hope it’s on Netflix. I’ll give it a watch.

reply

I know it used to be on Netflix UK, not sure about now. The cast is much more age appropriate in it. I like Thompson and Rickman, but they were just a little too old.

reply

As much as I liked Rickman...pairing him with a teenage Winslet was gross.

reply

Colonel Brandon is described as being on 'the wrong side of 35', in the book, so he is considerably older than Marianne. Alan Rickman was 49 when he acted the role. Such age differences were not unusual at the time in which the story is set. In fact, Sir John Middleton, a widower, who was Mrs. Jennings' son-in-law, is more her contemporary. so her daughter must have been considerably younger than he. Our modern notions of attraction and marriage do not apply in Austen's novels, as they did not in her time among the middle and upper classes.

Colonel Brandon had served in the military (and may have made his fortune) in India, so his being unmarried is not surprising. Young women were encouraged to marry as soon as possible to an eligible (meaning as well-off as possible), suitor. Age did not matter, and usually, neither did love, as is exemplified in the marriage of Thomas Palmer and Mrs. Jennings' daughter Charlotte. She is a constant irritation to him, and they are obviously mismatched. (Loved Hugh Laurie's snide rejoinders to his wife, as well as his kindness to Eleanor when Marianne falls ill.) If he had been able to choose, (I don't think it was told whether he needed to marry Charlotte for her fortune or if it was the other way around), he might have married someone like Eleanor.

Marianne is fortunate to finally fall in love (she would probably have preferred spinsterhood to marriage without it) with the calm, centered older Colonel Brandon who had been in love with her long since. I have never thought of Alan Rickman as handsome, but he was attractive and had a lovely, mellifluous voice.

reply

No need. Great acting. Great cast. Beautiful cinematography. Excellent film.

reply

Not every movie made needs to be re-made. This is one of them. We have classically trained actors, the like of which it isn't easy to fnd these days. In any case, the film industry needs to come up with new ideas instead of remaking films that cannot be improved upon, or stretching out franchises (Star Wars comes to mind) that have been done to death with diminishing returns.

reply

I should like to see Michelle Obama play Elinor. At first she would seem too old but she has the toned arms of a 19 year old ax tosser.
To play Edward, I would go a very different way, opting to pick an actor of great feebleness rather than goodness, none could be better than Don Lemon.
For the role of Marianne I'd go with Whoopi Goldberg. Her youthful locks and wonderfully scratchy voice will sell her angst when she loses Willoughby (played by Donald Trump).
For the role of Brandon, a good and decent fellow, I would cast Wanda Sykes.

reply

There's no point because it's already been done very well. Not only that, but today it would have to be woke, a nauseating prospect.

reply