MovieChat Forums > Clueless (1995) Discussion > Why did Hollywood fall in love with Hall...

Why did Hollywood fall in love with Halle Berry and not Stacey Dash?


https://www.lipstickalley.com/threads/why-did-hollywood-fall-in-love-with-halle-berry-and-not-stacey-dash.3973752/

*Were actresses around the same time

*Same age

*Biracial blacks

*Not impressed with either acting abilities but

*HELLA GORGEOUS

Why did Halle get roles intended for Caucasian women (her claim to fame) while

Stacey Dash admittedly wrote that casting directors who she was cool with would state, "Sorry Stace - this role is intended for a Brunette WW"?

reply

If I had to guess, it would be because Halle was known for doing more "black films"...acted great in every one of them, but still was typecasted to being in urban film's...she was black but light skinned, and in the racist eyes of Hollywood, the safe black woman to eventually cast in mainstream blockbuster roles. Where as Stacey just outright tried to audition for the roles that the casting directors had already made up their mind were for a white woman.... without really putting in the work that halle had been putting in. Flash forward to 2003 and Halle hit it big with Monster's Ball and BOOM...it catapulted her career to A-list status where her race didn't matter any longer.

reply

I'd argue that Halle was on the cusp of stardom by the time she made The Flintstones. She then suffered through a string of unfortunate flops, particularly the misconceived BAPS, but by the time she made Introducing Dorothy Dandridge, for which she won an Emmy and a Golden Globe, she was catapulted back into the A-list, and started getting cast in high-profile parts in X-Men and Die Another Day, even before Monster's Ball won her an Academy Award.

reply

I loved baps lol

reply

Considering what a right-wing nutter Stacey Dash became, isn't it a relief that Halle became the bigger star?

Besides, apart from Clueless, what was Dash famous for?

Halle was a Miss America runner-up who went on to appear in Jungle Fever, Boomerang, The Flintstones and Losing Isaiah, all before Clueless was released. And fwiw, I think Halle is far sexier (not that we should even be pitting Black women against one another to begin with), and has displayed more acting range (I staunchly disagree with whoever said her acting ability was 'unimpressive'). Plus, I don't feel that Dionne was very representative of the experiences of most Black women either in the 90s, or even now, whereas Halle played a range of roles, and her character in Boomerang likely resonated with more Black women, because she was a sweet, self-made, middle-class career woman rather than a spoiled little rich girl.

reply

not that we should even be pitting Black women against one another to begin with


Why? What makes them different than Indian women? White women? Hispanic women? or Asian women?

reply

Why compare two entirely different women simply on the basis of their race?

reply

Actually, the OP did not make the comparison simply on the basis of their race as you suggested,

The OP listed five reasons both women are the same type and would be competing for the same roles. Race was one. Just as it would be if the same question was asked about Winoa Ryder and Jamie Gertz.

Type plays a large part in why actors/actresses are hired, especially early in their careers.

My answer to the OP's actual question is Halle's career flourished because she has more charisma, though additional factors are no doubt in the mix.

reply