MovieChat Forums > Batman (1989) Discussion > Sean Young's recent comments about getti...

Sean Young's recent comments about getting injured and being replaced by Kim Basinger as Vicki Vale


https://www.thedailybeast.com/sean-young-on-surviving-hollywoods-many-toxic-men?source=entertainment&via=rss

And you’d been cast as Vicki Vale in the first Batman and then lost the part.

I broke my arm. They did spring the horse-riding thing on me, and I fell and had an accident. Could they have kept me on the show and shot around my arm? They probably could have. I think [producer] Jon Peters had this hard-on for Kim Basinger, and he saw an opportunity to exit me, and he did. And no one ended up being very happy with that choice. But it is what it is. I had an accident and then got walked to the door.


https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/batman-1989-deleted-scene-sean-young/

reply

It's a bummer. She for sure would have been catapulted to super fame.

reply

Maybe. She was already famous but it's very noticeable that after Blade Runner and Dune there is almost nothing memorable. Even in a series like Tender is The Night, which I do remember as excellent, I didn't realize she was in it.

reply

https://lebeauleblog.com/2014/11/20/what-might-have-been-sean-young/5/

Young was originally cast as Vicki Vale opposite Michael Keaton in Batman. However, during rehearsals she fell from a horse and broke her collarbone. As a result, she had to drop out of the movie and was replaced at the last minute by Kim Basinger. After the injury, the horse riding scene was cut from the movie.

Fallout: Batman was a big movie. It cemented Basinger as an A-list star. It’s easy to imagine that it would have had a similar impact on Young’s career. Instead, Young’s career cooled through the 90s.

Verdict: Missed Opportunity

reply

I still wish Tom Selleck was Indy.

reply

sucks for Young to have missed out on the biggest movie of the 80s like that ..but its pretty unthinkable for anyone other than Basinger to have starred in that iconic 1st Batman movie and she brought an almost fairy tale princess aspect that Burton obviously digs (esp at the end) and was like a retro movie star siren from the 30s/40s but also very modern looking woman of the late 80s .. much like the overall movie with its retro noir present day aesthetic .. (i guess Young had a similar thing going on but in a brunette way in Blade Runner which i guess is why Burton initially cast her?)

reply

I'm starting to think that Sean Young may have a point when she says that they could've plausibly worked around her injury.

*Hollywood was able to work around Jeremy Renner's broken ARMS.

*When Brad Pitt broke his arm on the set of Seven, they wrote it into the movie

*Nicole Kidman injured her knee while filming Moulin Rouge and she was able to film her scenes sitting down

*Daryl Hannah chipped her elbow in eight places and still has a scar following an accident on the set of Blade Runner. They worked around it

https://www.quora.com/What-are-some-of-the-most-interesting-ways-an-actors-injuries-were-incorporated-into-the-story-of-the-series-or-movie

https://www.ranker.com/list/real-actor-injuries-written-into-movies/jim-rowley

https://www.digitalspy.com/movies/g25448/real-actor-injuries-in-movie-blade-runner-brad-pitt/

https://www.looper.com/221131/actor-injuries-that-were-written-into-storylines/

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WrittenInInfirmity

reply

I of course, don't know for sure how Sean Young would've or could've played Vicki Vale compared to Kim Basinger. It's obviously the biggest "What if..." story to come out of the 1989 era Batman film franchise besides how differently would Batman Forever had turned out had Michael Keaton played Batman instead of Val Kilmer and Billy Dee Williams graduated to becoming Two-Face.

reply

"sucks for Young to have missed out on the biggest movie of the 80s like that"

More like the most overhyped movie of the '80s. E.T. and the two Star Wars movies that were released in the '80s were bigger domestically.

reply

I think she would have been a better choice for Catwoman in Batman Returns

reply