MovieChat Forums > Idris Elba Discussion > Stinks up everything he's in

Stinks up everything he's in


Currently revisiting 'Prometheus' (yeah, I know.....shoot me) and whilst this movie has several other problems....Idris Elba doesn't help matters either (I'd actually forgotten he was in it, truth be told)

Does Elba enhance *any* movie?

I've just never gotten his over-shouty style of acting. He seems a bit too full of himself (both as characters and in interviews) I'm aware that women seem to like him, but is his career built entirely on and around that, because I see zero acting talent on screen He's like the black Tom Hardy....completely useless, vastly overrated, yet oddly (and inexplicably) over-employed?

reply

Totally disagree. I think he is a fine actor and has never stunk up anything.

reply

Luther was good.
Suicide Squad was good and he was a good addition ...

reply

I thought he improved movies that he shows up in. And I'm looking forward to seeing him in the next Sonic movie.

reply

Excellent actor.

reply

"Tom Hardy....completely useless, vastly overrated"

Hmm sure. This is so over the top that it's obvious that you're trolling. I hope that the attention we're giving you is soothing.

reply

Really?

Jesus....Standards have clearly slipped, when you find yourself defending Tom Hardy?
I'll take a guess and say you likely think DeCapriro and Pitt are 'great' actors also (oh dear)

Care to mention any of Hardy's great performances?

Wow...(quote) "It's obvious that you're trolling" how utterly 2002 of you.

reply

I think Tom Hardy is a great actor and was excellent in Bronson, Locke, Warrior, Legend and The Revenant.

Calling someone overrated isn’t a statement of fact, it’s merely an opinion and just shows that you personally don’t acknowledge the talent of an actor that many people praise. Of course you’re entitled to that opinion but dismissing those who disagree with you borders on arrogance.

reply

(quote) "....but dismissing those who disagree with you borders on arrogance"

Hmmmm?

reply

So no comment on the Hardy performances I mentioned?

reply

To be fair, you'd no more convince me how great they are, as I would convince you they weren't. Needless to say, I found those movies to be lousy (unless you equate silly accents and constant frowning/scowling as 'great')

I'm not being glib, nor catty when I say I genuinely feel sorry for people who like Hardy, Elba, DeCaprio or Pitt, Hanks, Clooney, etc (I really do)

I'm fully aware that taste is subjective.....but most actors nowadays leave me cold. Awards, praise and platitudes are handed out like candy these days.
Personally, I think it's likely down to generations demanding their own classics (regardless if they exist or not) therefore you get substandard shite like Goodfellas, Fight Club, Pulp Fiction, Se7en, The Departed, Drive, Wolf Of Wall Street, Inception, The Irishman (etc, etc) all heralded as 'masterpieces' (simply because they must be) and the defence of such movies, usually results in regurgitated, fifth-hand studio hyperbole from 'jaded' cinemagoers (and little else) The consensus rules.....OK.

It's a crying shame that 21st century audiences never had their own Mitchums, Marvins, Douglas, Holdens, Coburns, Lancasters, or even Bronsons?

Instead (and at very best) they get the sub-par (fag-end) work of (once-greats) Hoffman, Eastwood, Pacino and/or DeNiro (and likewise Scorsese)

A likewise crying shame that audiences don't demand more than what they've currently got (it mightn't necessarily improve the situation) but at very least, it'd stop the praise of mediocrity (hence my Idris Elba rant)

reply

lol the most elitist garbage ive ever read

reply

Yes.

Really.

reply

I’ve only seen him in one movie which was Beasts of No Nation. I must say I thought he was great in that one.

reply

Excellent performance as Stringer Bell in The Wire

reply

I won't lie, my family and I were somewhat bothered seeing him in the first Thor movie. He did okay as Heimdal, but honestly, he really didn't fit in the Nordic myth setting. I don't care how diverse Asguard was, or if this sounds racist, a black man in viking armor looks wrong.

Incidentally, Idris got tired of doing the role after a while.

reply