MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Describing DVD/Blu Ray as 'obsolete'

Describing DVD/Blu Ray as 'obsolete'


Hey there,

I had this experience at work whereby I was sort of ridiculed for watching stuff on Blu Ray instead of streaming. The general attitude out there is that discs are 'obsolete' and streaming is the way modern, happening people should watch stuff.

This confuses me, because 90% of movies (probably more?) are not available to stream.

The question is, how can discs be considered obsolete when they are the only way to source 90% of movies? Are we supposed to ignore film history and just forget that all those movies exist?

reply

i am a streamer all the way

reply

May I ask, how do you watch movies that’s aren’t available to stream?

reply

HE DOESNT...WHICH IS PROBLEM 4 OUT OF 34 WHY STREAMING SUCKS.

reply

i have plenty of choices.

reply

YES,YOU DO...FOR AN OCD VIEWER LIKE MYSELF THOUGH...STREAMING CANT COMPETE WITH THE NUMBER OF OPTIONS WITH PHYSICAL MEDIA.

reply

aren't most of your dvds sitting there and collecting dust??

reply

THEY ARE SITTING...THE DUST PART,NOT SO MUCH...IM ALWAYS SIFTING THROUGH AND PULLING FLICKS OUT TO REWATCH,USUALLY A FEW DOZEN AT A TIME...I DONT WATCH TELEVISION THOUGH,LIKE AT ALL,EVER...SO MY DISCS HAVE NO COMPETITION FOR ATTENTION.

reply

Same here. I watch almost no tv programming at all. I did watch Dexter and Breaking Bad though. 😀

reply

I WILL WATCH SHOWS ON DISC...I REWATCH THE ENTIRETY OF THE OFFICE OFTEN...DISCS DISCS DISCS...BUT THE ACTUAL SCHEDULING,COMMERCIALS,CHANNEL FLIPPING?...I AM 100% RETIRED.

reply

I’m with you man. I’m through with commercials.

reply

I am 50-50 between movies and tv.

reply

I PROBABLY COME OUT 85-15 MOVIES TO TV...ALL ON DISC THOUGH.

reply

I’ve purchased many films on DVD or VHS because they aren’t available streaming.

reply

I appreciate that, but do you still have a DVD player when you want to see a movie that is unavailable otherwise?

reply

I do not have a dvd player and I move on to another movie.

reply

I’m trying to figure this out myself, so that helps. Cheers.

reply

UNCLE HOWNOS WAS DIFFERENT BEFORE THE...WAR.NOW HE JUST SITS IN HIS ROOM BREAKING DISCS AND MY HEART😭

reply

I have a Roku streaming device coming for father's day. Not exactly sure what am suppose to do with it.

reply

SOMEONE EXPLAINED THE ROKU TO ME...I STILL DONT GET IT😵

reply

do you subscribe to any streaming services at all?

reply

I PAY FOR NETFLIX FOR MY DAUGHTER...IVE SPENT MAYBE AN HOUR ON THERE IN THE MONTHS THAT WE HAVE HAD IT.

reply

I get Netflix for free - Ker-ching!

reply

You connect it to your tv and download apps and games to it and then watch movies, shows, listen to music, check the weather, and play games on it.

reply

SO...IT DOES WHAT A CELL PHONE DOES,BUT FOR YOUR TV?

reply

Pretty much.

reply

I LEARNED SOMETHING😁

reply

Learning is fun!

reply

It's hell fitting it in your pocket though.

reply

For me, with a 4k TV and Ultra-Blu Ray player, I do prefer discs.

It's expensive to buy a disc but if it's a movie I want to watch over and over, it's worth it.

There's something cool about 'owning' a movie, that you don't feel with streaming. Plus with streaming it's got a vibe of the movie always been switchable. So if I get bored, out it goes. The movie has to justify it's viewing by holding your attention. It is a different dynamic with a disc. You're more committed.

There are still more options to discs like director's commentary and making of specials, as well as deleted scenes etc.

So they're not 'obsolete' and people with really good home theatre setups will want the ultra-blu-ray for the best sound and picture available.

reply

I'm in a rural area with bad internet service and I absolutely hate this mindset. People ridiculing people for still using discs. Most of humanity doesn't live in areas with super high-speed internet. Where I am, internet speed isn't much better than it was 20 years ago. Streaming isn't always an option. And as you said, the selection available for streaming seems to be very sparse in any case.

reply

They sound like my brother, who is very quick to label "old" technology as "obsolete" as if that makes him appear cool. But I keep my old VCR tapes from yesteryear.
And as for DVDs, new movies are still released in that format. So how is it "obsolete"?

reply

Yeah, but for how long though? For the record, while I do prefer streaming, I'm never getting rid of my DVDs, especially my Criterions.

reply

I say we must take one year at the time. But I don't see any reason to stream movies at the moment.

reply

THATS THE FEAR OF ALL PHYSICAL MEDIA...HOW LONG WILL THEY KEEP MAKING IT...ITS A TERRIFYING THOUGHT...AT LEAST THE ALREADY EXISTING STUFF WILL ALWAYS BE WITH US.

reply

Where it gets really confounding is when you find people for whom CD, DVD and Blu Ray is obsolete...but they embrace vinyl. (For the record - no pun intended - there's absolutely nothing wrong with vinyl, but the combination of eschewing DVD but embracing vinyl is quite the head scratcher).

I think you touch upon a good point here: why are people so keen to call discs obsolete? To appear cool, maybe, and for the media, it's great clickbait.

reply

To be fair to my brother, I don't believe that he has listened to vinyls either for decades. But yes, I hear that they have made a come-back with some people. One of these days, it will maybe be cool to use VHS tapes again too!

reply

Discs are definitely not obsolete. I love buying dvds and blu rays. I do streaming as well, but as you mentioned, there are lots of films not available to stream and a film could be removed from a streaming service at any point.

reply

It's truly amazing how many movies are not available to stream at any specific time. I test this from time to time on justwatch.com. Anything made more than 10 years ago is a bit rare for streaming. Now buying digital copy is a different story and rent/streaming is slightly better but I'm not paying 5 bucks to stream a 20 year old movie.

As for discs. If you have them in YOUR POSSESSION, they are YOURS. They CANNOT be taken away by Google/Amazon/Apple//etc. Don't laugh, digital media has been taken away from many people for many reasons.

reply

I wonder how streaming companies get away with such a sparse selection? Why isn't there more demand, or rather why don't they respond to the demand for a more comprehensive selection?

I can only conclude that either the demise of DVD is greatly exaggerated, or demand for the missing titles doesn't exist. I don't know how else to reconcile the disparity.

Edit: The rent/stream option is better as you say, however it is region specific. The selection available on the US iTunes store, for example, is far superior to that available on the Australian iTunes store. Neither selection is a patch on what's on disc, however.

reply

I wouldn't worry about what other people think, as long as you're happy, who cares?

reply

That's very true, of course, and an important mindset in life, but sometimes other people's logic eludes you so you want to gain some insight into why they think the way they do.

reply

People who think they are obsolete obviously don't care for all the bonus material DVD's and Blu Rays come with. You often get special features, deleted scenes sometimes and audio commentaries. Gotta love audio commentaries. Unless all these get transported over to the streaming websites along with the movies themselves, physical copies should never die.

reply