MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Unexpected Reactions to Movies You've Re...

Unexpected Reactions to Movies You've Recommended or Shown Others


Sometimes we get excited to share favorites with our friends and loved ones only to realize that it doesn't line up with their tastes.

Once I tried to show a friend The Iron Giant, but he couldn't make it beyond 20 minutes into the picture and wanted to turn it off, saying it was too dumb for him. We then proceeded to watch Beavis and Butthead.

I went with my sister to an early screening of The Fountain, hyped for a an ambitious and profound experience. She laughed each time Hugh Jackman displayed intense emotion. Conversely, I saw it later that year with my girlfriend at the time, and she seemed really somber afterward, telling me: "You didn't say it was going to be a sad movie."

What takes the cake, though, is La La Land. I watched it early last year with someone I was dating at the time who possesses a narrow taste for anything outside of a Hallmark movie. She showed visible disinterest during the film, fidgeting in her seat and frequently getting up. By the time the credits rolled, she sighed a sigh of unimpressed boredom before looking over at me, no doubt noticing my eyes welling up. I was feeling particularly vulnerable at that moment, at which point she glared at me and yelled: "THAT REMINDED YOU OF YOUR EX, DIDN'T IT?!" Then she proceeded to launch into more than two hours of yelling alternated with begging for sincere reassurances, which are kind of hard to do when you've just been verbally lambasted. It was at that point when I realized I had made a huge mistake.

Have any of you ever experienced a surprising response during or after showing someone a movie before?

reply

I love The Usual Suspects, so I decided to watch it with my parents. It seems my mother was just confused at the end, so she was far from enthusiastic. I really thought she would be as blown away as I was. I mean, she did like The Sixth Sense.

But was your girlfriend right? Did it remind you of your ex???

reply

At that point it made me recall those times with my formed betrothed, yes. It just so happened that La La Land's story paralleled some of my own experiences. I've just never seen someone be so bored during the viewing of a movie only to launch into a two-plus hour diatribe immediately afterward.

As for Usual Suspects, my dad rented it on video as soon as it came out, and I watched it with him, cross legged on the floor. Around the middle I blurted out to the room: "I think Kevin Spacey is Keyser Söze."

reply

Ah, so she had a point!

Sure, but did you also see coming that the whole movie you just saw was a made up story primarily based on some bulletin board? I consider that the real shocking twist of the movie.

reply

I thought Titanic was a mess and I told my wife who didn't appreciate it. She told me to "Shut up." We haven't discussed that movie since.

reply

[deleted]

She was crying over the movie and my criticism was a bit too soon. I was not relegated to the basement over this incident.

reply

[deleted]

I promised to watched Boyhood with her. I have put it off got quite awhile.

reply

Haha, that's a pretty divisive movie. Intriguing that Titanic won so many Oscars - yet none for acting.

reply

Those 11 Oscars look undeserving to me.

reply

Best Picture
Best Director
Best Art Direction
Best Cinematography
Best Visual Effects
Best Film Editing
Best Costume Design
Best Sound
Best Sound Effects Editing
Best Original Dramatic Score
Best Original Song

I guess I get most of those, except Best Picture and Best Director.

reply

No one pays attention to nine of them.

reply

True, but the movie probably deserved some of them.

reply

Well you have no taste in film. Don´t annoy your wife with that.

reply

I actually liked Titanic. I even had the Special Collector Edition Boxset DVD. My wife is into it just for the song. The frickin' song.

Funnily, she bought the Titanic Soundtrack CD then complaining that there is only one Celine Dion song in it. Everything else were the movie scores (instrumentals.) It's just like watching the movie but without dialogs and no pictures. Bizzare.

Unsatisfied, she then bought the Celine Dion album CD which has the My Heart Will Go On in it only to be even more dissapointed because all of the other songs were mediocre at best and were in totally different genre than the Titanic song.

I lol'd.

reply

One time was enough for me.

reply

I watched it twice.

reply

Nothing outstandingly surprising. But I did once suggest a viewing of What Dreams May Come to my younger brother many years ago. It had a really profound impact on me when it was first released, and I thought as an artist he would really enjoy it even just stylistically. My brother and I were close at the time and we shared a lot of similar interests and likes. But this film? He didn't really like it or get it.

That's probably it film-wise. I've also had people who don't like TV shows I've recommended, like Smallville, but I understand that.

reply

Some films can be divisive like that. I've been moved by fare that my viewing partner saw as less than impressive and vice versa. It adds to the discussion.

reply

One of my ex is a horror fan. She always wanted to see the latest horror movies. I don't get horrors. I think it's not scary (hey, it's just a movie!) and most of the time horror movies characters are just dumb people making dumb decisions. I just don't enjoy that kind of entertainment.

Someday I watched The Rite on DVD and I thought it was pretty good. I recommended it to her and she didn't like it. I was a Catholic and she wasn't so maybe not many people are into Catholicism.

Okay. Another time I recommended her Sanctum. I really like it. She didn't. I don't understand.

The only movies we both kinda agreed on were The House of Wax (the one with Paris Hilton) and Drag Me to Hell. Those movies are somewhat enjoyable to me.

reply

It's nice when you can find that kind of middle ground. I dated someone who didn't much care for grim horror fare like Silent Hill or Frailty, but we both enjoyed schlock like the House of Wax remake and Drag Me to Hell.

reply


"Annihilation". I thought it was excellent, a 9/10. I took a friend to see it. Her reaction after the credits ended: "Weird."
Of course to be fair, a lot of people shared that opinion with her.


😎

reply