MovieChat Forums > The Many Saints of Newark (2021) Discussion > Giuseppina was poorly written (Spoilers)

Giuseppina was poorly written (Spoilers)


Giuseppina - presented throughout the movie as a primary character and the clever, ambitious immigrant-mistress of Dickie - inexplicably decides to make a brainless confession to him on a deserted beach that she had sex with his arch rival for whom who he holds racial contempt. She does this knowing full well that he is a psychotic mobster who is suspected of having savagely murdered his own father (and her husband). You watch this and you think why the hell would she do this?

reply

It was all so bizzare. She slept with Harold because Dickie wasn't giving her enough attention and was curious about sleeping with a black man.

And he didn't need to be a psychotic mobster, you don't tell any man who loves you to death that you slept with someone else in a deserted area.

I remember just talking to the screen after the words came out her mouth, "So She's dead."

reply

Movie-wise, my biggest pet peeve is when a character makes a completely illogical decision - so yes, her confessing out of the blue for no reason whatsoever pissed me off.

reply

Especially a character who’s been written as enterprising and clever up to the point of her incomprehensible decision

reply