MovieChat Forums > The Woman King (2022) Discussion > Has anybody here seen it and have an hon...

Has anybody here seen it and have an honest review?


The trailer for this movie looked cool. It looked like the kind of war movie like Braveheart, 300, etc., that plays fast-and-loose with history, but has coolness and action in abundance.

Zipping around online I see that the critics can't love it enough (100% Rotten T's, 75 on Metacritic) while audiences are scorching it on IMDb.

The film is the latest "woke battlefield film" like Joker and Ghostbustiers which received a lot of hate prior to release; people were galvanized and polarized just walking in to theatres.

Does anybody have an objective take on the movie, who can give me a (preferably spoiler-free) quick review of the good and the bad of this film?

reply

I just saw it and I was thoroughly entertained. It’s quite spectacular visually with some truly adrenaline-pumping battle scenes. The story is quite simple but it holds your interest despite the lengthy running time.

There’s been so much said about the agenda of this film already by people who chose to pass judgement before even watching it, but if you go into this expecting it to be anti-white propaganda I think you’ll find yourself mislead. It’s actually more a straightforward story of courage, resilience and fighting for honour.

Viola Davis is as fantastic as you’d expect, I would not at all be surprised to see her accepting an Oscar for this soon. Equally deserving is Thuso Mbedu, a lot of the emotional weight of the story rests on her shoulders and she carries it effortlessly.

I thought this was a good, old fashioned Hollywood epic and an extremely well-made and entertaining one at that.

8/10

reply

I think I'll probably watch it when it's streaming, but I didn't see it in theatres. I'm not even sure if it's still playing anywhere, but I don't think I'd go. I'm very, very choosy about films I see in theatres (for budget reasons and spare time usage, mostly), but I liked the trailer.

There are a few people here, like yourself, who have provided level-headed reviews that aren't hyping the film because it's a "feminist" or "diverse" and who aren't tearing it down because it's "woke" or "anti-male". And, thank you for taking the time to let me know about the movie.

Yeah, these days it seems like prejudging films is the standard procedure. Worse, this judgement often comes pre-trailer, let alone pre-film, and everybody taking these opinions becomes almost entirely galvanized the second they take them up. I first noticed it with Ghostbusters (the straw that broke IMDb's back for message boards (RIP)), then with Joker (for the opposite crowd), Captain Marvel, and so forth, on up to the latest batch (Rings of Power, She-Hulk, Woman King, etc.)

I don't like it because it makes it hard to actually like something or dislike it. It makes it hard to figure out if the property has an agenda or not because just by reading these opinions it can get hard to see what the film actually is. It's why I've avoided Rings of Power. I can't get "it's woke" out of my head, so I know I won't be able to just relax and enjoy it (or dislike it, but on my own terms).

reply

No problem Ace, and thank YOU for creating a thread where people who have actually watched the film can share their thoughts.

I totally understand what you mean about the tornado of opinions on a film before it’s released. I try not to read too much into it though, if you’re going to great lengths to trash a film you haven’t seen, your opinion doesn’t hold that much weight to me and certainly doesn’t influence my decision to watch it. This and Bros were two of the most maligned films here before anyone had even seen them, and both turned out to be entertaining, enjoyable movies. I liked Bros a little less than this, but it was still nowhere near as terrible as you might expect if you went by the ranting of people who oppose the very IDEA of the film.

I would say that The Woman King is definitely worth seeing on the big screen though, although I respect your decision to wait until it hits the streaming services. The visuals and battle scenes alone make it one of those films that really do benefit from the cinema experience.

reply

Thanks for saying so. I like discussing movies, not so much politics, so it's nice to have a thread about the actual movie.

I'll see if it's still playing near me, but I might have missed it.

I'm not that interested in Bros, but just because nothing in the trailer really grabbed me, plot-wise or character-wise. I am mildly interested because I'm a big Community fan and I love Jim Rash. But the main writers, director, and star aren't people I really know anything about. I might stream it, but probably not. Definitely gonna re-watch Community, though...

reply

I saw it yesterday, and it was kinda lame. In the first scene he appeared in, I thought Boyega was about to start a Rap song and dance sequence. The occasional humor is flat and so is the acting from most of the cast. Even Viola Davis cant save it. Lashana Lynch is as terrible she has been in her recent outings. I am neither white or black (I am from India/asia), so the political tone didn't bother me. You can enjoy it mildly, specially the 3 action sequences. Its pretty avoidable otherwise.

When it released i remember the rating fell way below 6 in IMDB and honestly that's correct in my opinion. It somehow shot upto 6.7 and fooled me into watching it.

reply

Many compare TWK to The Legend of Hercules but with negros.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1043726/?ref_=nm_knf_t4

reply