MovieChat Forums > Hush (2016) Discussion > Would the police really come?

Would the police really come?


The ending left me a bit confused, unless I missed something. Seems like she dials the cops, hangs up (or stays on the line for whatever reason, not sure) and the police arrive at her house.

Is this realistic?
Is this the common procedure in (I'm assuming) the U.S.?

I can only say that if I called the police where I live and hung up, there's no way they're gonna show up, not even from a land-line (actually happened last week, my young niece dialed them by accident and hung up), so It just got me wondering about these kind of scenes.

reply

She doesn't hang up, she just puts the phone down with the call still engaged. I can't say for sure about the U.S.A., but I live in Canada and if you dial 911 here, even if you don't say anything, they will track your call and emergency services will come. If you call and hang up, they will call you back, and if you don't answer, they will send emergency services anyway.

reply

That's about right. Especially if you call 911 and don't talk, they will definitely send someone.

reply

I see, thank you for the info.
Very impressive I gotta say (though completely logical), it's what I assumed kinda happens - and should - in certain places.
Glad to see it actually works like that --
I guess the cops here just don't give a flying F..

reply

not to mention her alarm was going off the whole time in the background so they would've heard the noise over the phone, even if no one was speaking

reply

If you call 911 in the US and hang up (or don't respond/speak to the operator) they will send someone. (I'm 99% sure this is true in all states--it is certainly true in the three different states I've lived in).

About 5 years ago I'd just moved into a new place (VERY rural). During the night a pillow slipped off of my bed and on to a heater in my room. The pillow began to catch fire and the fire alarm went off.

I hadn't realized it was a new-style alarm system, so it made a huge racket and in my sleep-addled state I thought it was a security alarm going off, so I grabbed a phone and ran and hid (yes, I was hiding from a fire *sigh*). I dialed 911, but it seemed to me that the phone wasn't working properly and so I disconnected the phone. As I woke up more I remembered that, oh yeah, this house didn't have a security system. I took care of the pillow (it was smoldering, not really in flames) and went back to bed.

20 minutes later I woke up to a fire truck pulling into the driveway full of volunteer fire fighters. The 911 operator had caught a second of the sound of my alarm going off, recognized it as a fire alarm, and dispatched the fire crew.

When I was younger, there was even a thing on our phone (offered through one of the carriers), where if your phone was off the hook for more than 3 minutes the phone company automatically dialed 911 on your behalf. This was for a situation where you need help, go for the phone, but only manage to get it off of the cradle and don't manage to actually dial anyone.

reply

I live in UK and some how my landline rang 999 -I had gone to the shops-came back to find police at my door! Apparently it was some kind of fault ! But based on my experience they would.

reply

Yes, they would come. Obviously she would have told them she was deaf. She lived alone so she knew that she could call for help and they would come right away. I guess most if not all deaf people who live alone in a wood have these kind of deals. Would have been unrealistic if they didn't come.

reply

Is this the common procedure in (I'm assuming) the U.S.?


Yeah its fairly common. Lots of emergency situations where someone would call 911 might not allow for the person calling to succinctly describe the situation to dispatch. Better safe than sorry when it comes to this stuff. If the cops are sent to a house and its just a dumbass 4 year old kid playing with the phone, oh well. If they ignore the mute 911 call and it ends up being someone dying of heart attack/domestic abuse victim who couldnt speak/home invasion victim hiding/etc..., they screwed up.

reply

If you called them with a cell phone, nope, they wouldn't come. No way to know who you are or where you're calling from. Cell phone companies can triangulate cell phone positions using their towers, but they will only do so with a warrant signed by a judge, and that takes time to get.

reply

Her number could be registered and they try the address

reply

Ideally, the cops will still be sent. But sometimes in the US, when people call 911, the operator is impatient to go on break or just "Ain't got no time fo dis!", so they just hang up and don't report it to anyone.

reply

>>>operator is impatient to go on break or just "Ain't got no time fo dis!", so they just hang up and don't report it to anyone.<<<

Which would likely get them fired if anyone found out about it.

reply

I think that may have been the case. Those examples were from real life news articles I’ve read over the past couple of years

reply

That rarely happens. Those lines are recorded continuously. It would definitely get an operator fired if not brought up on charges.

reply

True, but the sad thing is that it happened even once is too many times.

reply