MovieChat Forums > Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016) Discussion > Batman V Superman Shorter Fan Edit Remov...

Batman V Superman Shorter Fan Edit Removes the DCEU Storylines


http://screenrant.com/batman-v-superman-fan-edit-no-dceu-storylines/

After introducing a new version of Superman in Man of Steel, Warner Bros. decided to launch their own cinematic universe about DC characters. Their first film did not do much to lay the foundation of the larger world that Superman was a part of, but Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice made sure to change that, and do so quickly. The two and a half hour epic pitted DC’s two most recognizable characters against one another to start, but by the end of the film, they were predictably fighting a much bigger threat together, all while setting up the future of the DCEU.

This was hardly a surprise as the film’s title indicated dual stories and motives in place, but in the mind of most, the film succeeded with one of these storylines and not the other. The movie’s third act was loaded with “Easter eggs” for what is to come – including introducing future Justice League characters – and detracted from the one-on-one superhero fight fans were interested in seeing. Well, now one fan has taken it upon himself to edit the movie down to just tell the Batman vs Superman part of the story.

Fan editor, Reese Eans, uploaded a five-part edit of the Ultimate Cut for BvS that strips away any setup for future DCEU storylines and characters, making the film’s sole focus the fight between Batman (Ben Affleck) and Superman (Henry Cavill). This No Justice cut of the film removes 69 minutes of footage from the 3-hours and 3-minutes runtime of the Ultimate Cut, thus creating a much more manageable 1 hour and 46-minute edition. You can see the first part below and each of the following parts by following the links.

One of the biggest changes, outside of the third act, that this edit makes is the removal of Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot). Since the edit completely removes the final battle against Doomsday – the sole purpose for Wonder Woman to be involved at all during the film – her previous brief encounters with Bruce can by cut out and not have that big of an effect on the movie. With Doomsday and Wonder Woman absent, the film’s third act does not contain the QuickTime cameos of Flash, Aquaman, and Cyborg, which were a common complaint among fans, but the cut does not, however, remove the much maligned Martha scene because it is actually vital to the conclusion of the Batman vs Superman confrontation.

With the complete reworking of the third act, this cut also takes moments from earlier in the film when Lois and Clark are living their normal human lives and puts that at the end. This changes the narrative entirely with Superman not being dead in the world, and the two setting aside their differences for the betterment of humanity, but also because Bruce is able to see Superman as a person and not a monster because of the pivotal Martha scene.

All in all, this is cut completely changes the film and how – if this was the version that was canon – the DCEU would be set up moving forward. Clearly, the DCEU is not moving forward in a world where Batman and Superman are friends, Wonder Woman will be introduced in a World War I origin story, and other Justice League characters will get proper introductions in Justice League. So even though this edit may not actually matter to the DCEU, it’s still a great reinterpretation of the film we got.

reply

while I can't judge if this cut is good or not because I haven't seen it and wont watch it...

but I find this JUST SAD.

I can't believe That A Studio messed up a movie this big and this important So bad that Now the only way to find some enjoyment in it is to completely make different cuts of the movie.

first it happened with The Studio itself....The Theatrical cut of BvS was such a disaster and so universally hated, WB Literally had to release a completely different Cut of The film on Blu Ray just to try and save face and smooth things over...

I mean its not everyday, That A Studio literally has to release A different cut of the film just so you can finally understand what The Motives of the villain were.

The Theatrical Cut was absolutely awful and was panned by the overwhelming Majority.

The Ultimate Cut was clearly an improvement, but an Improvement of An Awful film, so at best The Ultimate Cut was still a bad film.

and Now Fans are forced to make Cuts Like this In an attempt to savage some sort of Decent movie.

The facts are BvS was a once in a lifetime movie, that fans had been dreaming about and waiting for...and its just stunning that A movie this important could turn out so horrifically that theres now been 3 different cuts of the film in an attempt to try and make it A decent film.

whats even more Shocking is somehow WB did it again in their very next film with Suicide Squad...You'd think WB might learn something after Screwing up BvS with Awful Edits and Different cuts....But dope, In their very next film, They decide to Badly panic and wildly interfere in Suicide Squad Post Production, Suicide Squad was a completed film, and WB decided to completely try and change The Tone of an already completed film and brings in a Editing company to completely make a different cut of the film in an attempt to "Lighten the tone"...Of course it resulted in another universally hated film, that once again got A "Different cut" released on Blu ray in hopes of saving face...

lol I just dont see how DC fans can be happy about different cuts....I mean I guess the OP must be happy about this new cut or he wouldn't have posted this...But Me, I just can't get over the fact that In order for these New Cuts to even exist, it means WB failed and Screwed up the Original movie so horrifically, People now have to desperately created New Cuts to try and salvage this movie...

I mean can these new cuts bring some enjoyment, ya maybe....but wouldn't ou much rather of just had A Great Film instead


reply

I thought Wonder Woman was one of the few bright spots, but I understand the editorial logic.

reply

https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/6f5wq1/batman_vs_superman_should_have_been_two_different/

One movie to handle the Batman vs Superman arch, and one movie to handle the Doomsday arch and start to introduce the Justice League.

reply

If this anti-DCEU edit removes all of Wonder Woman's contributions to this film, it's a mistake not worth watching. That characters participation in this story is far, far beyond a mere easter egg.

reply

These days I'm waiting for fan-edits with more anticipation that the actual movies. That's how bad movies are these days.

reply