To the haters


One bright note: what you liked still exists

If you really don't like Disney's takeover of the series, good. Let it go.

Giving it any attention, positive or not, is a waste of your time. Just because Disney is not catering to your fanbase doesn't mean you're any less of a fan. It just means you're not a slave to Disney's marketing. Let's be honest, Star Wars is not a work of art anymore. It's a product. You dont need it. Enjoy your favorite star wars parts and let the new stuff go. You'll be happier for it.

reply

Ok.

reply

While I certainly agree with your take that it is a corporate product now, and not a work of art; telling fans to go pay attention to something else they like is not really a great option. Especially since there is nothing quite like star wars, and to see it go from something you love to something you hate can leave a certain sense of grief. People are entitled to their grief.

Also what are they supposed to move onto? Most of the major franchises are all making the same type of product appeal to 'new' younger and more progressive fanbase. The bright note you point out of "what you liked still exists" means all these fans get to enjoy is the same product from 30 years ago or more and never have anything new to be excited about.

Think people are happier when they have nothing to look forward to in the terms of film future? Even my family members that I split in opinion with in the Disney era star wars admit they are not looking forward to the new one and we agree that in terms of all films being produced there is not one series based film to look forward to. What the hell is there to be happy about, that the only enjoyment we can get out of film is from the past?

reply

I get your point, but it falls back into the same problem of nostalgia marketing. When we are so easily manipulated because the movie is part of a franchise, we only support the same franchises. When we look at movies as a franchise, we lose sight of the individual films which allows disney to continue making more crap. I refuse to do this.

Let them go, stop giving them money and look around. There's a lot of new filmmakers and stories being made. They're just buried or looking for funding. As a horror fan, I've seen what happens when art becomes a product (friday, nightmare, Halloweenetc...). It sucks. But, theres always new surprises and stories. We just have to seek it out. Eventually, you find movies like Trick R' Treat, Behing the mask, Henry: Portrait of a serial Killer, equillibrium, don't breath, Saw 1 (another victim of franchising), etc.

Star wars ended, but the matrix was amazing and not noticed until after theaters. Lord of The Rings was Given to a b-grade director who made gore flicks. He made one movie in 3 parts. It was an epic film experiment.

There's hope, one just has to open his/her eyes.

reply

Your point is valid, but you have to remember moving on involves dropping investment into a universe. there is a human tendency to get caught up in 'sunk costs' where the amount of resources dedicated to an investment is used as justification to continuing adding more resources. It takes time to build a familiarity and comfort with a story/universe. Rather than moving on to something new most would rather stay and enjoy the one they know. Filmmaking is changing in the modern era; the ability of television to match the production quality of film has made it so in terms of story telling a 2 hour movie can't compete with a 10 hour series.

What you talk about is fine for watching one off films such as the ones you mentioned, but there are different forms of watching film. The type when we want an epic long duration adventure, such as Lord of the Rings and Star Wars, and the type we watch for a quick 90 minutes ride. Major Hollywood production is leaning away from the latter because there is not as much money in it. And at the same time all of the franchises (which hollywood is pushing more and more) and all going into the toilets (terminator, Jurassic Park, Star Wars, The Hobbit films, what else). This is why Amazon and Netflix are where I think the better 1 off movies are being made now, but this means less theater experiences.

The Matrix became a franchise and I think was not a very good one outside the first. Lord of the Rings almost happened by accident. I watch about 10 hours documentary on the making of the film and so many things had to go wrong for it to go so right. But both the matrix and lord of the rings are around 20 years old. What good franchise films have been produced since then. The only one that competes in terms of quality is Marvel, but that was treated more like a Television series with the Avengers films being like the 'season finales' and that is why it worked so well. Now everyone is trying to mimic that formula and failing.

reply

As I read your comment, all I see is the franchise being your main draw. To me, this is sad. Great movies dont need multiple movies to be a good story. Most marvel movies stand on their own without the franchise. A lot of DC movies fail because they rely too heavily on making a franchise. Lord of the Rings was not a franchise, but one movie released in 3 parts. Star Wars has been failing because they're focused on making a franchise instead of separate movies that stand on their own. Its like divergent or the hinger games. When you know there isn't a conclusion until 5 movies later, why bother going to the thester. May as well wait for it to be online and binge at that rate.

Perhaps that's the biggest fail. Too much focus on making a franchise instead of one entertaining movie at a time. But then sgain, marvel spoiled modern audiences. Now everyone is looking for that big film franchise fix. Too bad modern audiences couldn't learn from Friday the 13th, Saw, or paranormal activity. In the end, they were more about selling the name than making a good movie.

reply

Perhaps I was not clear. Franchise films are by far not my favorite, in fact in my top 10 favorite movies you will notice either no franchise films exist on it, or they were single films that launch a franchise later: Such as Alien or Jurassic Park.

I love films like Gladiator, John Carpenter's The Thing and Big Trouble in Little China, The princess bride and so many other great 'one off' films. But as I said, Franchise films are a little different. Most would not watch Lord of the Rings in one sitting and would need to watch it over multiple days, same with Star Wars and most other franchise films. But a single film does not have the same amount of screen time as a franchise or television series, so there is less time to become invested into it. You watch different movies for different reasons, one of my favorite recent movies was The Nice Guys. That was a solid film.

I agree movie producers trying to compete with television and Marvel is taking movie making in the wrong direction. Everyone is trying to force a Cinematic universe and for the most part it is not working. But I do not think there is anything inheritance wrong with trying to produce a franchise as long as the films are solid, like with MCU. The problem is since there is more money to be made in franchises everyone is trying to do them now. which does suck because I like both.

reply

It's not Star Wars. It's everything. Every single franchise right now is woke-controlled. The woke-believers are spreading through modern media and tech companies. Once they enter a company, they only hire other woke believers and fire unbelievers, until they control the company.

And the very few cases they can't control a company, like some videogame companies from eastern Europe, the media just campaign against them (cough Kingdom Come cough Cyberpunk cough).

reply

Yeah, it's lame now, but so was the early 90's. Things changed as good movies made money. Some in theater, ithers on the rental msrket.

What's really awesome is the fsct that we can make movie ourselves. I made a crap movie with friends for $2000. Honestly, we knew it wasn't good, but it ended up better than we thought it would be.

reply

The Left has always controlled Hollywood and the news media...they're just more brazen in their messaging than ever before.

reply

OR - treat it like a comedy take on Star Wars not on the same continuity as the OT.

That's what did for the prequels and now I can watch them having a good laugh!

reply

That's a great way to enjoy yourself. Good call.

reply

[deleted]

This is smug and arrogant.

Yes, the good ones still exist, but who said we didn't want Disney Star Wars to be good? Couldn't Disney Star Wars have been good under different leadership? Yes, right? And that's an extreme disappointment. A franchise that I enjoyed has the potential to be expanded and this is THE BEST they came up with? It doesn't even seem like they were trying.

Pretend Star Wars was your child. He/she was a great kid when young and grew up to be a fine teen. Of course as the parent, you were proud and love him/her very much. However, when he/she became an adult, something happened. He/She fell on bad times and because he/she hung out with the wrong crowd he/she didn't amount to the full potential he/she could have been.

As a parent, don't you still love your child regardless? Aren't you going to be disappointed in his life in regards to what he/she could've been or done with his life? That, in a nutshell, is Disney Star Wars. It was the #1 draft pick that turned out to be a complete bust due to the influence of the people around it.

If venting my dissatisfaction to my child is the only thing possible that would get the child to salvage his/her life, then I'm doing so. Thus, the dissatisfied fans have a right and SHOULD vent their dissatisfaction with the idiots that are running the franchise.

reply

Star wars isn't like your child. You did not create it and you have no say in its development. You can want it to be better, but that's not your call or responsibility. That's like a sports fan yelling at a sports team through the tv. In the end, it's useless.

Star wars is a product used by Disney to get you to spend the money you or your parents worked for. It has no feelings, no growth, and no real impact on your life beyond what you let it have. Why waste your time when you admit they don't care?

There are more meaningful things you can do. Like actually raising a child, finding a different movie, or making your own story. Complaining because your dissatisfied is ok, but by the third letdown, why bother? You know they won't match your expectations. Just let it go. What you loved still exists. Going back and hating what's being produced is just crazy. That's like giving into the dark side.

reply

What part of the word "pretend" did you fail to understand? My child lives his own life and when he becomes an adult his life is his. I don't choose the path for him, he chooses it on his own. However, as a parent or a fan, I have aspirations for his potential and his future. Is that so hard to understand? And if the potential is squandered can I not be disappointed in both circumstances? Do you understand that?

It isn't useless. I don't have to support the product and I can vent my dissatisfaction. Does Disney want to maximize its profits? If I'm not part of that equation, I'll do my best take deny them as much profits as I can.

Disney cares. Do you think they wanted fans to dislike it in the first place? Everything they are doing is damage control while still appearing to keeping a united front. They know Rian Johnson screwed up and Bob Iger knows KK is the cause, but they can't publicly admit it.

Venting my dissatisfaction takes all of 5 minutes at a time. Call it mental break. The thing that you can do is simply not read the complaints rather than bitch about it.

reply

Op... fuck you, you stupid asshole.

reply