MovieChat Forums > The Walking Dead (2010) Discussion > The Other Side of the Walking Dead's Idi...

The Other Side of the Walking Dead's Idiot Plot Syndrome Is Still Idiotic


This was an evening of Idiot Plot Syndrome on THE WALKING DEAD. One of the very few substantive things that happened in the first half of the show's present season is that Maggie usurped the spineless Gregory's leadership of the Hilltop community. But when the second half launched, it was as if the writers hadn't been watching their own show, a fairly common phenomenon with TWD, and everyone was back to treating Gregory as if he was still in charge. Though Gregory had just betrayed them and tried to turn over Maggie and Sasha to the Saviors, our heroes even laid out before him their plan to organize a rebellion against the villains. Not much happened on "The Other Side," tonight's installment, but the ep did underscore the danger posed by Gregory, as he's clearly poised to spill his guts to Negan lieutenant Simon. Merely poised, of course--if wouldn't be TWD if it didn't try to artificially stretch every bit of what passes for plot to the absolute breaking-point.

Tonight's a-plot was the Saviors stopping by Hilltop to appropriate its doctor after Negan torched his own. That's all. The b-plot followed Sasha and Rosita as they made their way to the Saviors' compound to try to kill Negan. A few eps ago, both admitted they expected this to be a suicide mission. If they attempt such a thing and are killed, captured or even identified, the likely outcome is that the Saviors descend on the various communities in force and out for revenge, an onslaught both Sasha and Rosita know full well those communities are, at present, entirely incapable of resisting, but Negan murdered their co-beau with his bat and as TWD's writers are sure, women are just completely irrational children who let their emotions drive them, even if it puts everyone in danger...

The full article is here:
http://cinemarchaeologist.blogspot.com/2017/03/walking-dead-92.html

reply

It felt like they borrowed the writing staff of Fear the Walking Dead for this one... not good at all.

reply

SPOILERS: The highlight of The Other Side is Jesus' confession, oh, and at the very end Dwight watching Rosita.

reply

[deleted]

The whole plot with Rosita and Sasha makes me so angry. Especially Rosita. She is not a team player. She's a stubborn hothead who thinks she knows everything but she just keeps getting other people killed and still doesn't learn from it. A war needs an army and the army needs to operate as a unit. Not a bunch of loose cannons doing their own thing.
How many times does it take before they learn that retaliation will always be on their loved ones, not just themselves?
And Rosita can't do it alone. She would have failed alone just like her and Sasha together will fail. Carol could do it alone, but Rosita is no Carol.

reply

You're right about Rosita. And the only reason for her proposing this whole lame-brained plot of killing Negan to Sasha is to have Sonqeeqa Martin-Green tag-along on her "mission" so the writers can kill-off Sasha's character. The actress is moving on to a bigger role on a new TV series, so her character gets its obligatory TWD spotlight episode before she's offed from the cast list.

reply

Thats true! But couldnt they find a "better" way to get rid of her? Her motivation is so non-realistic because all of it happens in such a short amount of time: Falling in love, revenge on the lost lover, hating the ex, loving the ex, giving her life for the ex - WTF? All happens in a few days.

reply

Sasha didn't even want to go on this stupid hairbrained mission, it wasn't even her idea, and now she's gonna get killed for no good goddamn reason. The plot line makes me angry. I am just adding Sasha's name to the list of people that Rosita is responsible for their deaths.

reply

One, never Just one, is it, one thing I found fault with as a woman who has carried to term 5 children (and a little bit of vanity here..I don't look it) is when Maggie was having the sonagram? Isn't she supposed to be either 2 or 5 (can't remember) months pregnant??? She was as flat as a flitter. ANY woman during the 2nd month starts showing, she has that mound, and this is when normal women usually need to loosen the belt or get another size because they can't squeeze it in anymore. Rant over!

reply

Yeah, I wish I'd remembered to write about that. It's my recollection that Maggie actually was showing for a while. She certainly isn't anymore.

reply